Conspicuously absent from the policy platforms and campaign rhetoric of the announced 2020 Democratic presidential candidates is discussion of the war in Afghanistan, which recently became the longest-lasting armed conflict in American history.

This silence is interesting given the broad consensus among Americans that the U.S. military should withdraw from Afghanistan. A 2018 YouGov poll found that 61 percent of Americans support withdrawal. That figure is even higher among veterans — 69 percent support leaving Afghanistan.

But lately, only three 2020 candidates — President Donald Trump, Sen. Bernie Sanders and Sen. Elizabeth Warren — have taken a public stance against continuing certain American conflicts, including the war in Afghanistan. Mr. Trump’s announcement that thousands of troops will be withdrawn from Afghanistan and Syria was even met with widespread condemnation from his own party. A recent bill written by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, and supported by virtually every other Senate Republican, criticized that decision. It was ultimately passed in the Senate with a vote of 68 to 23.

Mr. Sanders and Ms. Warren, meanwhile, recently signed a pledge to bring ongoing U.S. military conflicts to a “responsible and expedient” end. The pledge, written and organized by the veterans group Common Defense, seeks to bring an end to the long-running and free-wheeling wars the U.S. has waged since 2001, particularly in Afghanistan.

Advertise with us

The other candidates have been more tepid in to take a public stance against the war. Cory Booker, Kirsten Gillibrand and Kamala Harris, as well as Mr. Sanders and Ms. Warren, all voted against the Senate’s condemnation of Mr. Trump’s withdrawal proposal. This is something, but voting against a condemnation in the Senate doesn’t tell Americans much about what will come of America’s longest-lasting war. Withdrawing the U.S. military from Afghanistan may be one of the very few policy points upon which Mr. Trump and his progressive challengers agree.

But if withdrawing from Afghanistan is a well supported position, why have so few of the Democratic candidates offered a vision for how they would support it?

If the Democrats wish to compete with Mr. Trump in 2020, and surely they do, each candidate must put forward his or her own vision for the future of U.S. involvement in Afghanistan. For now, Mr. Trump has the upper hand, as he has articulated a popular stance against the best wishes of his party. If he can be swayed remains to be seen.

But the Democrats must prove that they, too, are interested in seeing the men and women of the U.S. armed forces return home safely, and they need to offer a plan for how it will be done. All citizens, but especially soldiers and their families, deserve to know what is to come of this protracted and deadly conflict.