A proposal that would encourage disability examiners to use social media to evaluate Social Security disability benefits claims is ill-conceived and ripe for misuse.

Tucked away in its budget request to Congress last year, Social Security acknowledged it was considering using social media networks more prominently when assessing disability claims. It argued that looking at a person’s posts or photos could “increase program integrity and expedite the identification of fraud.”

In theory, this is not an awful idea. If someone is receiving government disability benefits but posting pictures from the golf course, it is easy to see how one might believe something fishy is occurring.

But social media is often deceptive. What a person posts today might not have actually happened today. In fact, people are far more likely to post pictures of themselves during happier moments than, say, when they are laid up in the hospital.

Advertise with us

Furthermore, not all disabilities are visible to the naked eye and certainly may not be on display in a photo. For example, lupus and bipolar disorder both qualify a person for Social Security disability benefits, but would be near-impossible to observe simply through social media.

Michael J. Astrue, the former commissioner of the Social Security Administration, told the Senate in 2012 that “social media sites are not exactly clear and reliable evidence.” He emphasized that “professionally trained fraud investigators” are still needed to evaluate disability claims.

Mr. Astrue was right then and he is right now. Investigations of disability claims must not rely on rickety evidence discovered via social media. Currently, disability examiners refer suspect claims to Social Security’s inspector general. At that point, social media may be used to confirm the suspicions. This is a sound strategy.

There is no question that fraudulent disability claims are a problem. They can cost the government a great deal of money and deprive truly unwell people of a valuable resource. But disability examiners must remain committed to investigating each claim thoroughly, using reliable and well-evaluated evidence. Leaning too heavily on social media will only lead to more mistakes and more headaches for Social Security.