In the wake of two fatal crashes involving the Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft, U.S. airlines should voluntarily halt use of the planes until engineers and regulators find out what, if anything, is wrong with them.

Boeing, the manufacturer, should step forward and ask the airlines to stop using them for the time being.

This would be the responsible thing to do.

But if the airlines and Boeing won’t act responsibly, the Federal Aviation Administration must order the planes grounded pending an investigation into Sunday’s Ethiopian Airlines crash, which killed 157, and October’s Lion Air crash, which killed 189.

Advertise with us

Authorities in Australia, China, Europe, Indonesia, Singapore and other nations have grounded Max 8 jets —a Boeing best-seller rolled out just two years ago — and airlines in a handful of other countries have elected to stop using them temporarily.

In the U.S. however, Southwest and American airlines have refused to ground the Max 8 planes in their fleets, and the FAA so far has declined to make them. Such recalcitrance flies in the face of sound judgment, good customer relations and reasonable advice from one of the field’s leading experts.

Passengers don’t want to fly on these planes now, and that should be reason enough to keep them out of the air. On top of that, leading members of Congress and Jim Hall, the respected former chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board, have called for the planes to be grounded. Two unions representing airlines employees also demanded that the planes be grounded.

That begs the question: If flight attendants and other airline workers have concerns about the planes’ worthiness, why don’t the airlines, Boeing and the FAA? Perhaps the perpetually beleaguered U.S. airline industry fears the financial costs more than the potential human impact.

The plane operated by Lion Air, an Indonesia-based budget carrier with a spotty safety record, crashed in the Java Sea about 12 minutes after take off from the Indonesian capital, Jakarta. The Ethiopian jet crashed six minutes after taking off from that nation’s capital, Addis Ababa. Ethiopian Airlines is a major airline with a respected safety record, so Sunday’s crash immediately focused scrutiny on the Max 8’s possible technical shortcomings.

Advertise with us

The two disasters are similar in that both planes made a series of climbs and dips before falling out of the sky, raising questions about whether pilots were wrestling with a flight control system that wanted to keep forcing the planes’ downward. After the Lion Air crash, Boeing, regulators and airlines gave pilots special instructions on the aircraft’s flight control system.

Maybe it wasn’t enough.

As Mr. Hall noted in a story published by USA Today, Boeing redesigned the rudder on its 737 fleet following the 1991 crash of United Airlines Flight 585 in Colorado and the 1994 crash of US Air Flight 427 in Beaver County.

Perhaps a software fix for the Max 8’s flight control system or additional scenario training for pilots is necessary. No one will know until authorities get to the bottom of the Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes. Until then, the planes shouldn’t leave terra firma.