A convicted criminal who has been sentenced to jail loses his liberty.

He does not forfeit his citizenship.

Yet, many states restrict a felon’s voting rights — a cornerstone of citizenship — not just while the prisoner is behind bars, but sometimes long after his punishment has ended. Sometimes, indefinitely. Sometimes, permanently.

This flies in the face of a foundational principle of American justice, the principle of rehabilitation and redemption.

Advertise with us

This is bad. But, even worse is the fact that there is no even-handedness in the application of what has become known as felony disenfranchisement.

The United States is all over the map. In Maine, felons never lose the right to vote — not even when they’re in prison and not even if they’ve been convicted of first-degree homicide. In Delaware, someone convicted of bribery loses the right to vote permanently. In Pennsylvania and Ohio, a felon can’t vote while in jail but, upon release, can cast a ballot. In West Virginia, the right is restored only after completing probation and/​or parole. The variables can include the nature of the crime committed and whether the prisoner is serving his time in a state, federal or county lockup. Even the definition of a felony varies from one state to the next; Marijuana possession and drunken driving are felonies in some states and not in others.

The National Conference of State Legislatures reports that the general trend has been toward reinstating voting rights for felons — at least at some point. Currently, 14 states and the District of Columbia restrict felons from voting only while incarcerated. In 21 states, felons lose their voting rights during imprisonment and for some time following, usually while on parole or probation. Two (Maine and Vermont) have no voting restrictions. In the rest of the country, the right to vote is lost indefinitely.

On its face, the right to vote would seem a federal issue as it is encased in constitutional protection via the 14th Amendment. However, the amendment stipulates the right may be abridged for participation in “crime.” The U.S. Supreme Court case of Richardson v. Ramirez, decided in 1974, underscored that convicted felons in California could be restricted from voting, even after their time had been served. In the decades that have ensued since then, however, the Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause has been invoked in some state cases to invalidate the voting restrictions. It may take another judicial review by the U.S. Supreme Court to set precedent that will cure the pervasive disparities.

In the meantime, states should clean up their own messes, either by public referendum or gubernatorial order.

Advertise with us

There are no exact figures on the number of convicted felons in the U.S. but a study by the University of Georgia estimated that about 8 percent of American adults had a felony record in 2010 and that 6.1 million Americans (one in 13 were African-American) had been barred from voting in 2016 because of felony convictions.

That’s a lot of votes not being tallied.

As the saying the goes, “You do the crime, you serve the time.” When the time is served, full rights and responsibilities of citizenship should resume. And that means the right and the responsibility to vote.

As George W. Bush once said: “America is the land of the second chance and when the gates of the prison open, the path ahead should lead to a better life.”

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.