Most people expected the Senate Judiciary Committee hearings convened to consider Christine Ford’s accusation of sexual assault against Brett Kavanaugh to be dramatic and compelling.
They were. They are.
The hearings will be parsed closely in the coming hours and days. But we are likely to find what we found in the moment: More questions and no new answers.
The biggest question of all is: Why are we here now?
The Senate is not obliged to hold confirmation hearings at all. A nomination can be voted out of committee to the floor without hearings. And if all nominations are to be decided simply along party lines, maybe that’s what should be done.
But if there are to be hearings they should be in depth and the committee should do its due diligence as to a nominee’s qualification. Qualification has two aspects: jurisprudence and character.
Read More
The committee obviously failed in the second instance — to delve deeply into character — which makes one wonder if it also failed in the first instance.
The charges against Judge Kavanaugh should never have been set aside for a last minute political mugging. They should have been thoroughly investigated by the committee staff prior to the original hearings. If the committee felt it needed additional help, it could have asked the president to order a further FBI check.
The probing of the accuser and the accused could have happened behind closed doors, thus protecting both the privacy and dignity of Dr. Ford and the presumption of innocence for Judge Kavanaugh.
No, there is no constitutional presumption of innocence in a Senate confirmation process and, now we know for sure, no such practical assurance.
But in the American system, our controlling question must always be, “what if it’s not true?” not “what if it is?”
We base our concepts of justice not on compelling stories, or even on compassion for the injured, but on evidence and corroboration. Both are still wholly lacking in the accusation leveled against Judge Kavanaugh.
For the past 50 years or so, Supreme Court decision after Supreme Court decision has protected this presumption, telling us again, and again, that “he looks like the type,” or “if it wasn’t him it could have been” is not enough.
Because Sen. Dianne Feinstein withheld the charge against Judge Kavanaugh (for which she should be booted from this committee) and because the Judiciary chairman, Chuck Grassley, was in so deeply over his head, this botched process leaves two human beings damaged forever. And one of them, clearly, is already damaged.
Manifestly, something terrible happened to Christine Ford in high school. Whether Judge Kavanaugh did that damage is no more proven today than it was last week.
Anyone intimately familiar with the daily workings of the justice system will tell you that there is only one thing less reliable than an eyewitness — memory.
That is why we have another great due process tradition in America — the statute of limitations.
Of course the Senate is only bound to “advise and consent,” which is a political function, not a juridical one. Votes, based upon perception, not reason based on evidence, will rule the day.
But is the highest deliberative body in the land worthy of being the highest deliberative body if basic standards of procedural justice are utterly irrelevant to it?
The hearings were not the circus everyone said they would be. Instead we saw a slow, stately train wreck, one that never had to happen.
So, half the country will be outraged if a man they regard as a would-be rapist ascends to the highest court in our system. Or, the other half will be outraged if a man they see as decent and qualified falls victim to a campaign of character assassination. This is what political malpractice has wrought — further binary alienation.
The American political system today is much like the American medical system. When the patient is dying he finally gets really good medical help, and the top professionals find their focus and seriousness of purpose. And it is usually too late — the damage has been done.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.