The politics of the Brett Kavanaugh nomination is now a matter of math. With a slim Republican majority — two votes — and female Republican senators greatly concerned, the nomination is in trouble.
And no matter what new “evidence” of Mr. Kavanaugh’s allegedly flawed character is introduced, in no matter what dubious ways, Democrats will believe Christine Blasey Ford and Republicans and conservatives will doubt her and believe Judge Kavanaugh.
Wouldn’t it be refreshing, indeed uplifting, if one Democrat expressed concerns for due process or one Republican worried that the woman’s story, in cases of sexual assault, must almost always be proven beyond a shadow of a doubt? (That is not true in this case, in which, for many, doubt has been suspended.)
Does anyone in America think freely and outside his tribe anymore?
The justice issues raised by the nomination also cut in two divergent ways: There is the feminist claim to justice for women, all women. That is a social justice claim. And there is the claim of procedural justice, upon which liberal democracy and western civilization are built: The right of the accuser to be confronted with evidence and his right to cross examine and refute.
The Kavanaugh nomination divides us by politics, by gender, and by perception and values. It is another battle in the culture wars. It is a fierce battle, and it will likely get worse.
Is there a way out?
Or at least a way forward?
In the long run, the only way forward is a renewal of credal American values and the placing of them above pressure groups, group think and echo chambers.
In the short run, there is also a way forward from, if not out of, our deep divisions. It lies in a grand bargain, the fine art of compromise, and perhaps a specific compromise.
The specific compromise would be this: The president gets his originalist with this nomination and Ruth Bader Ginsburg resigns and is replaced by a liberal.
The Senate leadership of both political parties, and Justice Ginsburg obviously, would have to agree, of course.
But this would end the political civil war, for the moment, or at least confine it to elections. It would also end, or retard, for the moment, the degradation of the confirmation process, the Senate and the high court.
One cannot imagine United States senators of 25 or 30 years ago behaving as senators did during the Kavanaugh hearings, not only the hyperpartisanship, but the childish preening, posturing, and bad manners.
One cannot imagine Justice Hugo Black or Justice John Marshall Harlan discussing publicly, for all the nation to consider, the loss of his virginity.
Enough. Let President Donald Trump, the deal maker, broker a deal: The Senate considers Judge Kavanauagh, or another originalist nominee, purely on his or her merits, and the president then sends a second name to the Senate, who is not an originalist, and perhaps closer to Justice Anthony Kennedy’s jurisprudence — Merrick Garland. Mr. Garland should have been confirmed when President Barack Obama nominated him two years ago.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.