Mollie Tibbetts’ father is entitled to everyone’s sympathy and respect. But he does not get to decide how his daughter’s death informs immigration policy in this country.
And that’s not because he’s not entitled to his opinion, but because we are all entitled to think this issue through.
Authorities announced on Aug. 22 that Cristhian Bahena Rivera, a farmworker from Mexico, was charged with first-degree murder in her death.
The discovery that the suspect in the killing of the 20-year-old Iowa college student is an undocumented immigrant from Mexico prompted a series of comments, including by President Donald Trump and the president’s son.
The conclusion drawn by many who heard the news was that, had America’s immigration and citizenship laws been functioning properly, Ms. Tibbetts likely would be alive today.
Of course it is impossible to know that, but it is a reasonable position.
Mr. Tibbetts, who lives in California, published a column in the Des Moines Register urging others not to “callously distort and corrupt” his daughter’s death to promote a political agenda.
No responsible person can argue that being Hispanic or being an illegal immigrant made this suspect more likely to kill someone. The former allegation is racist and the latter is unsupported by facts.
That’s not the point. The point is that Mr. Rivera was living in our country illegally. He had no legal right to be here.
Some Republicans are linking Ms. Tibbetts’ death to that false construct Republicans call the Democratic “open borders agenda.”
This, too, is a distraction. The Democrats do not have an “open borders” agenda any more than the Republican Party has a white supremacy agenda.
However, Democrats do share with Republicans the responsibility and the guilt for Mr. Rivera being able to remain in the United States because of their refusal to come to agreement on a sane and humane immigration policy.
Let’s be clear: Ms. Tibbetts’ killing is a horror and the only person responsible for her death is the person who killed her. Moreover, nothing anyone thinks about it makes it worse.
But this awful crime does touch upon the immigration debate and our current national dysfunctional policy. So all of us have not only a right to talk about it but also a duty to do so.
The country still needs a coherent and consistent legal immigration policy and a path to citizenship for “the dreamers” — students and children brought here illegally but through no fault of their own.
Let us grieve for Mr. Tibbetts, but keep talking.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.