After the last presidential election, many disgruntled citizens, most but not all Democrats, began demanding that the Electoral College be abolished.
Doing that would require an amendment to the U.S. Constitution. There are no signs that such a move would have the support of two-thirds of both houses of Congress or a constitutional convention, followed by ratification by at least 38 of the 50 states — the means that the Constitution provides for changing the Constitution itself.
The fact is, for most of American history the Electoral College has worked pretty well.
Indeed, you could argue that, since 1888, it has helped give presidential winners more legitimacy by magnifying their popular vote margins. Barack Obama, for example, got 51 percent of the popular vote in 2012, but a thumping 61.7 percent of the electoral vote.
But you could also argue that it has misfired twice in the last five elections, giving us the popular vote loser in both 2000 and 2016.
Al Gore’s popular vote margin over George W. Bush was less than one-half of 1 percent. But Hillary Clinton won nearly 3 million more votes than Donald Trump, although, if one puts her votes together with Jill Stein’s, the total is less than if one puts President Trump’s total popular vote together with Gary Johnson and Evan McMullin. By that reckoning, the conservative cause comes out ahead by roughly 750,000 votes.
Mr. Bush almost became an Electoral College victim. A switch of fewer than 60,000 votes in Ohio in 2004 would have elected John Kerry president — despite President Bush’s substantial national popular vote lead. If that had happened, Republicans would have been the ones calling for changing the Constitution to the popular vote standard.
The great thing about the Electoral College is that it both nationalizes and localizes the race. Instead of campaigning only in the big states, like California and Florida, to build up a popular vote, presidential candidates are forced to campaign in small states that are competitive, like Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, Minnesota, and Nevada.
Now a movement called the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is trying to get the legislatures of states with a majority of electoral votes to agree to award their votes to the presidential candidate who gets the most nationwide popular votes. Connecticut is the latest state to join the cause, and states representing 172 electoral votes have now done so. If this movement continues to build, there will almost certainly be a very legitimate challenge to the proposed change on constitutional grounds.
The Constitution only provides one way to change the way we elect presidents — by amendment. That could happen, but it would take much debate and persuasion, and many years.
The Founders made this sort of change difficult. And that is a good thing in the case of the Electoral College, both because of the law of unintended consequences and because the Electoral College has served the nation well over time.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.