It’s easy to understand what motivates bank robbers, con artists and many other kinds of thieves — the lure of easy money or the prospect of a lot of it.
But art criminals, especially those who perpetrate major heists, are a different breed. Do they steal hoping to sell the works to others, in what surely would be a small marketplace filled with risk? Or do they take something, as Pierce Brosnan’s dashing character did in the 1999 version of “The Thomas Crown Affair,” for the thrill of the steal and the satisfaction of possessing something famous or beautiful?
Why would a nondescript New Mexico couple have stolen a Willem de Kooning painting, “Woman-Ochre,” from the University of Arizona Museum of Art in November 1985? Jerry Alter was a music teacher and his wife, Rita, a speech pathologist. After they died, a nephew found the painting hanging in their bedroom, positioned so that it was visible only when someone was in the room with the door closed.
Pieces of the puzzle now are coming together, and the emerging portrait of the couple is not pretty. Mr. Brosnan’s character notwithstanding, art criminals aren’t dashing, just dastardly.
They’re better classified as kidnappers than thieves because they snatch things that are loved, leaving a vacuum and questions behind. Why steal the de Kooning, for example? What made it the object of someone’s desire? Why it and not something else?
Art criminals leave a hole in civilization’s cultural patrimony. They take from everyone, and that may be the reason the public remains so fascinated with the 1990 unsolved theft of 13 items from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston and now is riveted on the de Kooning case.
The authorities have not identified the Alters as the culprits, but the clues are mounting. A photo places them in Arizona the day before a couple walked into the museum and swiped the painting, the woman distracting a guard while the man sliced it from its frame. The thieves drove off in a reddish car; the Alters drove red cars. Years later, they even self-published a story about two women pulling off a jewelry heist.
Sadly, art crime isn’t all that uncommon. The FBI maintains a National Stolen Art File — described as a “database of stolen art and cultural property” — that lists dozens of Andy Warhol works alone. Add up everything in the database, and the devastating scope of art crime comes into sharp focus.
The FBI’s 16-agency art theft team says it’s recovered 14,850 items worth more than $165 million since 2004.
But it’s a losing battle. The de Kooning, missing for a generation, is valued at $160 million. The stolen pieces from the Gardner collectively are worth more than $500 million. There’s no putting a value, though, on the cultural impact of art that vanishes from public view.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.