Though it may serve the needs of only a small number of insurance consumers who want an insurance policy only for catastrophic care, President Donald Trump’s new health insurance initiative may be a building block.

It could be the first brick of foundation for a health insurance system that is based more on choice — a variety of personal and systemic choices.

If such a system cannot be built, the nation will almost inevitably move toward something like Medicare for all, hybrid solutions having failed.

Now that the individual mandate has been repealed, people are no longer required to have the comprehensive insurance required by the Affordable Care Act of 2010.

Advertise with us

The Trump administration has approved new rules for “short-term, limited-duration insurance.” One of the new rules is that consumers can buy these plans for a whole year, rather than just three months at a time, and they can be renewed for up to 36 months.

Short-term plans don’t have to take people with pre-existing medical conditions or provide benefits like coverage for maternity, mental health, prescription drugs and substance abuse treatment. They only fit a niche of buyers who want protection from medical catastrophes.

That’s not a big, comprehensive “solution.” But that sort of solution may not be practical or desirable. And this new approach does suggest something like a series of catastrophic insurance levels coupled with medical savings accounts, and then a Medicare-for-all system that would kick in at the level of many tens of thousands in extended medical expenses — the government as the ultimate catastrophic insurer.