Earlier this month, Ohio State fired an assistant coach on its football team, Zach Smith. The case has returned attention to one of football’s biggest problems: violence against women.
Mr. Smith’s wife recently filed a domestic violence protection order and he was charged with criminal trespassing, His firing has revealed that the police were called on Mr. Smith twice before, in 2009 and in 2015, for abusing his wife.
Ohio State head coach Urban Meyer said that Mr. Smith had violated one of the team’s core values, which is to respect women.
But Mr. Meyer also admitted that he had known about the 2009 incident — in which Mr. Smith allegedly slammed his then-pregnant wife against a wall — when he hired him for the Buckeyes’ coaching staff in 2012.
“What was reported wasn’t actually what happened,” Mr. Meyer said. “It’s a very personal matter.”
Mr. Meyer’s thoughtless comments, which shamelessly obfuscated the seriousness of Mr. Smith’s actions, are a painful reminder that much of the football world has not yet acknowledged the seriousness of domestic violence.
When a graphic video of then-Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice assaulting his fiancée in a hotel elevator was released in 2014, Rice was cut by the Ravens and cast out of the league. Many had hoped that the league, and football as a whole, would work to set a no-tolerance standard for those who commit domestic violence.
But over the past five years, 19 of the NFL’s 32 teams have had a player arrested for domestic violence. Four teams had players arrested for domestic violence within the past year.
Frustration with the NFL’s inability to deal with the issue recently led two domestic violence experts — Deborah Epstein, who is the co-director of Georgetown University’s Law Center Domestic Violence Clinic, and Susan Else, former president of the National Network to End Domestic Violence — to resign from the National Football League’s Players Association’s commission on domestic violence.
“Because I care deeply about violence against women in the NFL and beyond, I can no longer continue to be part of a commission that is essentially a fig leaf,” Ms. Epstein wrote in a Washington Post op-ed.
It is hard for advocates like Ms. Epstein not to be discouraged when a prominent league like the NFL does not take more substantive action to remove abusers from its game and when a top-tier college coach like Mr. Meyer downplays the severity of a subordinate’s actions.
Mr. Meyer has long held that respecting women is a “core value” of his teams. And yet, he hired Mr. Smith despite knowing about his history of domestic violence.
It is clear that football continues to have a domestic violence problem. But simply saying that respecting women is a “core value” or is an issue of importance does not mean anything when no change is enacted. Firing Zach Smith was the right decision for Ohio State to make now, but the right decision would have been never to hire him in the first place.
If Urban Meyer and the rest of the football world would like to prove their commitment to respecting women — who make up a substantial chunk of their audience — they would be wise to cast men like Zach Smith and Ray Rice from their midst entirely.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.