With a stinging judgment handed down earlier this month, the Wisconsin Supreme Court reasserted the importance of academic freedom at our nation’s institutions of higher learning.

The court determined that Marquette University had wrongly fired professor John McAdams, and violated its own faculty handbook in the process, over a 2014 blog post.

Mr. McAdams had used his personal blog to criticize a graduate instructor, using both her name and a link to her personal webpage, because the instructor had refused to allow a student to debate gay rights. “Everybody agrees on this, and there is no need to discuss it,” the instructor told the student.

After Mr. McAdams made his critical blog post, the graduate instructor started receiving hateful messages, including threats of violence.

Advertise with us

Marquette’s administration moved swiftly, summarily suspending Mr. McAdams without pay, canceling his courses and banning him from campus. The president of Marquette stated that Mr. McAdams’ potential reinstatement was dependent on his signing a letter that acknowledged his blog post was “reckless and incompatible with the mission and values of Marquette University.”

Mr. McAdams rightly refused to sign such a letter and brought suit against the university with the assistance of several nonprofit groups, including the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE).

Private universities generally enjoy a great deal of latitude in how they carry out discipline and handle personnel matters on their campuses. But Marquette’s faculty handbook clearly states that formal punishments cannot impair its professors’ “full and free enjoyment of legitimate personal or academic freedoms of thought, doctrine, discourse, association, advocacy or action.”

“The undisputed facts show that the university breached its contract with Dr. McAdams when it suspended him for engaging in activity protected by the contract’s guarantee of academic freedom,” the Wisconsin Supreme Court wrote in its judgment, which reinstated Mr. McAdams’ position at Marquette and afforded him back pay.

This judgment, while limited to Wisconsin, sets an important precedent that other states and academic institutions would be wise to examine.

Advertise with us

Academic freedom, which is the conviction that free inquiry and expression are of critical importance to the vitality of the academy, is fundamental to our education system. Without it, there would be no discussion, no debate and no progress.

Academic freedom cannot merely be a flowery rhetorical concept limited to handbooks and promotional brochures. It must be central to every college’s mission. As FIRE executive director Robert Shibley said about the Marquette case, “This ruling rightly demonstrates that when a university promises academic freedom, it is required to deliver.”

Colleges throughout the country should take care to promote and ensure academic freedom. At a time when civil political discourse is under attack, institutions of higher learning should be encouraging young minds to respectfully study and debate challenging or unfamiliar ideas.

To do otherwise, as Marquette sought to with its actions against Mr. McAdams, would only imperil civility further.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.