If confirmed, Judge Brett Kavanaugh will be President Donald Trump’s second pick for the Supreme Court. It is an inexplicable pick.

Judge Kavanaugh, a federal appeals court judge in Washington, has neither the pizzazz of Judge Amy Coney Barrett nor the gravitas of Pittsburgh’s Thomas Hardiman. He has the real world, up from the bootstraps, appeal of neither.

Instead Judge Kavanaugh is a wholly political animal who worked for George W. Bush in his White House and Ken Starr. He is an insider’s insider. Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell advised the president not to nominate him — too much baggage and too long a paper trail.

The president did anyway, consistent with his pattern: When you start to get ahead of the game, promptly shoot yourself in the foot.

Advertise with us

Judge Hardiman, by contrast would have been a sober, solid, and safe nominee. He was most recently confirmed in the Senate 95 to zero, and before that by acclamation.

Judge Kavanaugh will educate us on his jurisprudence. Let us have the confirmation hearings and listen. But there are three things to be said, as an immediate reaction, to his nomination:

Read More

First, this is not the nomination that the caricatured Donald Trump would make. It is not a flashy, divisive or reckless nomination. Instead it is a Bush-type nomination — rather dull and unimaginative. And one that will cost as much and be as hard to win as a daring one. It is neither conservative (like Justice Neil Gorsuch) nor groundbreaking. It is merely political.

Second, until Merrick Garland, this was the approach of Barack Obama: politics trumping law. He nominated two very bright and admirable women, Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor. But they are more left than center left.

And, third, center-consensus picks — judges chosen for their judicial temperament and professionalism — were once the norm. It all went off the rails with the Bork hearings in 1987 and the Clarence Thomas hearings in 1991 — both of which became three-ring circuses.

Advertise with us

In the former case, a scholarly conservative man was cast as a crazed zealot, and the term to be “Borked” entered the language. In the later case, a man of limited qualification was cynically nominated by a Republican president, and the proceedings then became a psychodrama — sometimes a tragic opera — about contested allegations of sexual harassment. Nobody behaved well in that chapter of our discontent.

Supreme Court nominees were always political in the large sense, but they were one step away from partisanship and two from ideology. Presidents were granted deference for their choice and the focus was on qualification. The Bork and Thomas fiascoes changed that. Donald Trump missed the chance to change the change. This nomination fight will be a partisan bloodbath.