While fighting in court to keep their Amazon bid a secret, local government and civic leaders have taken a second alarming step to shield their courtship of the online retailer from public view. They’ve signed a nondisclosure agreement with each other.
Officials have said that the incentives offered to Amazon will be publicly released, whether Amazon chooses to locate its second headquarters here or not.
Then why the nondisclosure agreement among Pittsburgh, its Urban Redevelopment Authority, the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, the state Department of Community and Economic Development and Philadelphia, also a finalist for Amazon’s HQ2? The agreement would remain in place for up to five years after Amazon gets its incentives here or decides to put its HQ2 somewhere else.
Are local officials playing a game of semantics? When they said they’d reveal the bid details even if Amazon failed to choose Pittsburgh, they didn’t say how long afterward. Did they mean five years later?
DCED spokesman Michael Gerber said the agreement wouldn’t prohibit any party from releasing information it brought to the process. But it would prohibit one party from releasing information another brought forward. That makes no sense; we’re talking about one bid, not pieces of a puzzle for which one entity or another is exclusively responsible.
Pittsburgh, Allegheny County and the state have defied orders from the state’s independent Office of Open Records to turn over the bid, which it ruled a public document. The nondisclosure agreement came to light only because of a court filing the state made as it continues fighting to keep the bid under wraps. Pittsburgh and the county also have gone to Common Pleas Court to try to keep the bid from the Post-Gazette and other news organizations.
In their earnestness to shut the public out, government officials act like they’re making plans for war, not wooing a high-profile company with taxpayer money. They didn’t even want Common Pleas Senior Judge W. Terrence O’Brien, who’s overseeing one of the many legal battles over the document, to see it.
During a hearing last week, Judge O’Brien suggested he review the document in private. It was a reasonable idea, but city and county lawyers said, no, they didn’t think it was necessary. Judge O’Brien later decided it was necessary and ordered the bid turned over to him.
Pittsburgh is right to pursue Amazon — HQ2 represents an investment of up to $5 billion and the creation of as many as 50,000 jobs over 17 years. But secret pacts are bad public policy that leave officials open to speculation that they’re being manipulated by big business and trying to put one over on the public.
The city and county have said that revealing the bid’s contents now would give the other 19 HQ2 finalists a competitive advantage, and they’ve promised to release the details after Amazon makes its decision. If Amazon chooses to locate here, they added, incentives will go through a public vetting and approval process. In light of the nondisclosure agreement, however, even that tepid commitment to transparency must be questioned once again.
The public has a compelling interest now — today — in knowing what’s in the bid so there can be an honest discussion about what’s been offered. Knowing later might be too late. Amazon has a record of holding officials’ feet to the fire — it recently helped to beat back a tax on major employers in Seattle — so there’s little reason to believe that leaders here will walk back anything they’ve offered Amazon if the company decides to put down stakes here.
Progressive leaders would have demanded negotiating with Amazon in the light of day and cajoled other bidders into taking the same stand. But so far, Pittsburgh’s leaders have shown more interest in kowtowing to Amazon than in leading by example. They must release the bid, disavow the nondisclosure agreement and be upfront about everything promised to Amazon.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.