Earlier this week, the U.S. Supreme Court issued two important and stinging rebukes to a concept that has resulted in some of the most egregious violations of the First Amendment: compelled speech.
Both Janus vs. American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates vs. Becerra focused on this governmental affront to the right of conscience.
In both cases, the aggrieved parties argued they were being compelled to lend their voice, in some form, to a cause with which they did not agree.
In the case of Janus, Illinois child support worker Mark Janus was forced to pay union dues to a public-sector union to which he did not belong. He argued that his money was being used to fund political causes he did not agree with.
In Becerra, California-based Christian crisis pregnancy centers, which often advise women against getting an abortion, were required by law to post information in their clinics about the option of abortion.
Over two days, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of both Mr. Janus and the California CPCs, issuing rulings that thoroughly and persuasively explain why the First Amendment does not permit compelled speech.
Justice Samuel Alito penned the majority opinion in the Janus case, writing that forcing non-union members to contribute union dues “violates the free speech rights of nonmembers by compelling them to subsidize private speech on matters of substantial public concern.”
In the majority opinion for Becerra, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote the California law was unconstitutional as “it could be seen as compelled speech for those in the CPCs that disagreed with the state’s stance on abortion.”
When issues of the First Amendment arise, it is usually concerning issues of being able to speak freely and express one’s own opinion, regardless of its contents. But to those who cherish free speech, compelled speech should be of equal concern.
The idea that someone could be compelled by the government to utter or tacitly support ideas to which they are morally opposed is not only unconscionable, but it is also illegal.
Those who are angered by these decisions should imagine a situation in which the government forced them to agree with state-sanctioned opinions on an issue like abortion.
That concept is, quite simply, an affront to liberty.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.