After being, justly, pilloried for days for the policy of separating immigrant parents from their children at the U.S.-Mexico border, President Donald Trump gave in last week.

He announced he would sign an executive order to end the practice, which is the law, but had not previously been enforced. Clearly the decision to enforce the law was made in order to pressure Democrats to pass immigration legislation amenable to the president. That turned out to be one of the greatest political miscalculations in recent memory.

In the end, a bad policy, unenforced by fiat, then enforced by fiat, was ended by fiat — the stroke of a pen on an executive order.

Meanwhile we still need comprehensive immigration reform, and the only reform that can pass is legislation that gives the Dreamers — mostly young immigrants who are here illegally — a path to citizenship and tightens border security, including “the wall.”

Advertise with us

That sort of legislation, and there are two such prospective pieces of legislation circulating on Capitol Hill, is often thought to be contradictory. But there is no inherent contradiction between enforcing the immigration laws and doing so humanely.

Moreover, and more important, there is no inherent contradiction between border security and a liberal, legal immigration policy.

Immigration policy is not a series of binary choices.

Someone who wants a secure border might very well also want more legal immigration. Indeed, this was the national, bipartisan consensus for years.

Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton both favored some kind of wall at one time. Both president Bushes favored maximum legal immigration. So did John McCain.

Advertise with us

Immigration, instead of a series of simplistic binary choices, should be a series of smart choices. For instance, we should maximize immigration of the technically skilled, because it is good for the country. And we should always welcome political refugees because that is who we are as a country.

Immigration policy should be a series of rational decisions. If we limit the posturing, partisanship and calculation, and simply do what is sensible and good for the country, we can reclaim the old consensus and pass legislation that is humane and protects national sovereignty.

Yes, to border security. And yes to legal immigration — a home for those who can contribute, need refuge, and follow the rules. We can and must have both. The choice is not binary.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.