The National Institutes of Health has pulled the plug on a study of alcohol use, with director Francis Collins citing ethical concerns that were “a matter of the greatest seriousness.”

Dr. Collins’ decision to end the study was in the best interests of science, the American public and NIH’s credibility. The public accepts as gospel NIH’s findings and recommendations on all manner of topics related to health, and ethically flawed research would undercut the agencies’ standing in ways not easily repaired.

The study was to determine whether having one alcoholic drink a day helped to prevent heart attacks. It was to be funded at least partly with industry money. But that kind of thing is not out of bounds, provided proper disclosures are made.

Concerns first were raised by The New York Times, and NIH ultimately concluded that some of the researchers were too close to people in the industry and did not properly disclose those contacts, all of which created the potential for bias. The lead researcher, Kenneth Mukamal of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, objected to NIH’s findings and defended the integrity of the study.

Advertise with us

Another federal agency, the Environmental Protection Agency, has been accused of ignoring science under the leadership of Administrator Scott Pruitt.

But NIH under Dr. Collins just made a bold statement about the importance of science and ethics. It’s a moment worth noting.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.