Social media are hailed for their power to connect people and communities, but Twitter and Facebook also do the opposite.
They are forums where anybody can criticize anyone else from a distance, and this degree of separation just might fuel the notion that harsh words lose potency as they hurtle through cyberspace. Do the trolls really intend to be as mean as they sometimes are? Even though the level of public discourse continues to sink in this country, some of the things people tweet and post — about women’s bodies, about children, about “American Idol” contestants — seem beyond the pale.
Now, a study out of the University of Pittsburgh has found a link between negative social media experiences and symptoms of depression.
In 2016, a team led by Brian Primack, a physician who directs Pitt’s Center for Research on Media, Technology and Health, queried nearly 1,200 West Virginia University students about their social media habits and experiences. The students, aged 18 to 30, also completed a questionnaire about depressive symptoms.
The researchers, who published their study in the journal Depression and Anxiety, found that the students’ risk of depressive symptoms increased 20 percent with each 10 percent jump in their negative social media experiences. The students self-interpreted the negative experiences, but they could have been such things as online disputes, unkind posts or being unfriended.
More research will be needed to pin down whether negative social media experiences trigger depressive symptoms, people with depressive symptoms gravitate toward negative social media activity or both. Dr. Primack suspects it’s a little of each.
In the study’s other big takeaway, one that throws a little cold water on social media’s purported attributes, the researchers found that positive social media experiences were associated with only a small decrease in the risk of depressive symptoms. The decrease was so small that the authors described it as statistically insignificant.
The study was illuminating and of practical benefit; the researchers noted that clinicians treating patients for depression might consider limiting their social media exposure. The findings are consistent with what is known about bullying, mental health issues and suicide. Harsh words can sting, sometimes for a lifetime, whether they’re delivered in person or from afar.
This is not the first time Dr. Primack and other Pitt researchers have raised a red flag about social media’s potential to adversely affect mental health. Previous studies have associated social media use with sleep disturbance, social isolation and concerns about body image in young adults and found that the more time spent on social media, and the more platforms used, the greater the risk.
People who are concerned “may want to consider ways to minimize their exposure to negative social media experiences and maximize resilience to these experiences,” Dr. Primack said. In other words: Step away from the machines, and go talk to someone.
Social media may well have the potential to be a force for good. But in the wrong hands, the evidence increasingly shows, it can do much harm. Dr. Primack’s latest study is one more reason for Americans of all stripes to tone down their rhetoric.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.