Among the powers of investigating grand juries is this one: They can name names, criticize people for their conduct, even if they don’t indict anyone.
That’s evidently panicked some of those who had been drawn one way or another into a grand jury probe of sexual abuse in the Catholic dioceses for Pittsburgh, Greensburg, Allentown, Erie, Harrisburg and Scranton.
An unknown number of unidentified petitioners went to court demanding the opportunity to give testimony, present witnesses and pose their side of the story before the 40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury comes out with what is expected to be a voluminous report covering decades of abuse by priests. The petitioners aren’t facing charges, but they may be in line for criticism that they hoped to head off with sales pitches to the grand jury or to a judge who would alter the report if he found their arguments compelling.
Cambria County Common Pleas President Judge Norman A. Krumenacker III, who supervises the grand jury, rightly told them to take a hike. Grand juries don’t give audiences and breaking precedent would be, well, a bad precedent. Accepting the petitioners’ demands, the judge said, would bog down and transform the grand jury process.
Grand juries are expensive to operate, and this one already has reviewed half a million pages of documents and heard from dozens of witnesses. Perhaps some of them now want to come back and have the last word. But there’s no reason to spend more taxpayer money or the grand jury’s time listening to people whose only goal is to keep their names out of the paper.
As state Attorney General Josh Shapiro correctly pointed out, and as Judge Krumenacker echoed in his order June 5, those criticized in a grand jury report have the right to see what’s written about them before anything is made public and to write a rebuttal for inclusion in the report. That’s good enough.
It’s human nature to want to protect one’s reputation. However, the purpose of the grand jury’s work is to shed light on a long-festering abuse scandal, and opening the door to possible dissembling and spin from those caught up in it runs counter to that goal.
While it isn’t clear who the petitioners were or how they fear they might be criticized, another grand jury’s report, issued in 2016 after an investigation of sexual abuse in the Altoona-Johnstown Diocese, offers some clues. That report called out the cozy relationship between civil and religious authorities and criticized some police officers, prosecutors and church officials for responding less than zealously to signs of priests gone bad. That kind of finger-pointing doesn’t help one’s standing in the community.
The petitioners may appeal Judge Krumenacker’s ruling, but he made the right call for the integrity of the grand jury process and the people of Pennsylvania. Interestingly, while the petitioners’ names remain a secret, the judge made public his order rejecting their demands. That may be a sign that Judge Krumenacker, after reviewing the grand jury’s report, will quickly make that public, too.
Two priests already have been charged through the grand jury’s investigation. Regardless of whether additional charges are forthcoming, the full story must be told.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.