In the pantheon of thankless jobs, school board member has to rank pretty highly. The position comes with little or no pay, yet those elected have to endure regular ear-beatings from parents, spend long evenings away from their families for meetings and make brutally tough decisions about schools, finances and curriculum.

Some make the sacrifice because of their kids or their communities. Others promise to make the sacrifice, then don’t, finding they lack the time or interest. There’s no shame in that. The work isn’t for everyone.

But school board members who can’t do the job any longer should resign and make way for those who will. The work is too important to go undone.

The Post-Gazette’s Matt McKinney analyzed attendance records for Allegheny County school boards over a 28-month period and found a troubling rate of absenteeism: 11 members missed meetings one-third of the time while four others were absent at least 25 percent of the time. The analysis covered only attendance at monthly business meetings, not the committee meetings that often precede them, so the true rate of no-shows could be much higher.

Advertise with us

A few examples were particularly noteworthy. Dharmesh Vyas, the Penguins team doctor, missed at least 19 of his Fox Chapel Area School Board meetings over the 28-month period.  Keystone Oaks School Board members David Hommrich and Robert Brownlee missed 23 meetings and 21 meetings, respectively, during that period.

School boards have nine seats for a reason. The directors are supposed to represent a range of viewpoints across a district’s communities, so issues big and small get a thorough vetting. Political antagonisms on school boards are legion, but all members have a role to play, even the director who finds himself a minority of one. Leaving the job to a small coterie of members is a recipe for bad government.

If a board’s seats are apportioned by ward or community, or if one director represents a community of interests, absenteeism has the effect of negating a constituency’s voice. That isn’t fair to the taxpayers, students, teachers or any other group. It’s hardly the right civics lesson for a district’s youngsters.

The board for the Duquesne City School District, one of the county’s most troubled school systems, apparently had the worst collective attendance rate. One member, Cedric Robertson, missed half of the meetings over the 28-month period. While the district has a state receiver overseeing it, the locally elected board still has work to do. Empty seats at the board table only contribute to the sense of malaise.

In some cases, employment responsibilities or protracted illness may take school board members away from meetings they’d truly like to attend. In that case, they should ask themselves whether others could do a better job, even if they like the work and want hold on to the seats.

Advertise with us

No one who failed to fulfill the basic requirements of a paid job could expect to hold on to it for long. The same applies here. The school board is about public service, and one has to show up to perform it.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.