The National Football League wants a federal judge to approve an independent special investigator to review brain injury claims from former players, fearing many are faking symptoms to get themselves a piece of a landmark settlement agreement.

This is a problem of the league’s making. Its long-term failure to address brain injuries in the sport created a liability that it’s now trying to circumscribe with cries of fraud. The judge overseeing the settlement must ensure that every legitimate claimant is compensated, even if that means giving some, perhaps many, the benefit of the doubt.

The settlement, reached in 2013, ends thousands of lawsuits from ex-players who claimed the league had evidence of the long-term effects of head injuries even as it let them batter their brains into mush. It’s been estimated that payouts will total as much as $1 billion, but there’s no cap. The higher the number of claims, the more money likely to be paid out. So far, the league has paid about $440 million for 432 claims.

With settlement administrators, doctors, psychologists, lawyers, diagnostic companies and other professionals all playing roles, the deal has created something of a cottage industry. Lots of people outside the NFL have a stake in getting as much money for as many former players as possible. Against this backdrop it’s easy to see why the NFL wants to pay only those who legitimately qualify.

Advertise with us

The settlement covers those diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s disease or other types of dementia. But the list of those injured by the game runs much longer. Every former player had his bell rung at least once, and even minor head injuries can have life-changing effects. Perhaps the NFL should thank its lucky stars that it hasn’t been hit with more lawsuits covering a wider variety of brain injuries.

The settlement has drawn about 2,000 claims so far, but the NFL isn’t just handing out checks. There’s a professional claims review process in place, and an astonishing 46 percent of cases have been flagged for a second look because someone suspects something fishy. Lawyers for the players said the current system does an adequate job of preventing fraud. It may not be perfect, but the NFL, which has some of the nation’s top lawyers on retainer, agreed to it.

Now the league wants another layer of protection with the appointment of a special investigator to ferret out improper claims. An investigator probably would find some abuses — more likely the fudging of a diagnosis than than the outright feigning of illness for profit.

But remember this adage: When you’re a hammer, everything looks like a nail. If an investigator approaches the job with an eye toward preventing fraud, a certain number of legitimate claims almost invariably will be sacrificed along the way, undermining the whole process.

The judge should nix the idea of a special investigator. The NFL shouldn’t be allowed to change the rules mid-game.