A team of Harvard researchers has found that as many as 4,600 people likely died as a result of last year’s catastrophic Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico. This revelation has renewed justified scrutiny of the federal government’s handling of relief efforts on the island, and its estimate that only 64 people were killed in the disaster itself.

An independent team of researchers led by scientists from the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health surveyed residents of Puerto Rico to assess how the hurricane had affected the island’s death rate. The researchers’ findings led them to conclude that the death toll is “more than 70 times the official estimate.”

The report found that many of these deaths occurred as a result of delayed medical care, well after the hurricane had passed.

The findings have sparked new questions about how the Trump administration handled the crisis in Puerto Rico from the point that Hurricane Maria made landfall in September 2017: Why was the aid so inadequate and so technically incompetent? And why, when the relief effort started out so poorly, was it never corrected and improved?

Advertise with us

Much like the controversy surrounding then-President George W. Bush’s handling of the devastation that resulted from 2005’s Hurricane Katrina, critics have argued that Mr. Trump and the Federal Emergency Management Agency are guilty of a major governmental fail here. Except that, in the case of Puerto Rico, most people never knew. The story went largely untold.

In fairness, the Trump administration was faced with the task of responding to two devastating hurricanes in a matter of weeks. Hurricane Harvey, which principally affected the state of Texas when it made landfall in late August 2017, is estimated to have caused $125 billion in damage, tying it with Katrina as the costliest hurricane of all-time. Hurricane Maria, estimated to be the third-costliest hurricane of all-time, struck just a few weeks later.

But more than $140 million was spent to assist victims of Harvey in the first nine days after the hurricane struck, whereas only $6.2 million was spent to assist victims in the first nine days after Maria.

Dozens of helicopters, millions of meals, and thousands of aid workers were dispatched to Texas within 10 days of Harvey making landfall. It took months for the same resources to reach Puerto Rico.

FEMA and Trump administration officials have defended themselves, arguing that the disaster in Puerto Rico posed unprecedented logistical challenges due to it being an island territory. Moreover, Puerto Rico was already in the midst of a government debt crisis before the disaster, and there were pre-Hurricane Maria concerns about issues such as the safety of the island’s drinking water. In other words, Puerto Rico was already in crisis mode with no way to really respond to natural disaster. Thus, the disaster devastated the island.

Advertise with us

That’s a fair point, but it does not explain the discrepancy between the federal government’s rhetoric and its efforts, or its paltry estimate of Hurricane Maria’s death toll versus the one put forward by independent researchers.

It is also worth asking where the U.S. media was on this story. Why was the incompetence and indifference not truly and comprehensively covered?

One very somber question looms over all the others: Since most of the casualties were consequential to the hurricane and in the aftermath of the disaster, how many of these 4,600 deaths might have been prevented?