Three stories in last week’s Post-Gazette illustrate the challenges and opportunities for developing the city for a range of markets.

On Wednesday, “Bloomfield Confronts Rising Cost of Housing” described the anxiety felt by some longtime residents, especially renters. Strategically placed, Bloomfield is catching the eye of serious developers. Rents are on the rise in the close-knit neighborhood of narrow streets and modest row houses. The leader of the local community development group said that “How do we keep Bloomfield Bloomfield?” is now the common refrain. In previous years, the focus was on attracting investment.

A visitor who read the story would sympathize with residents who are not benefiting from the change, but might also come away with the impression that Pittsburgh is showing signs of a boomtown. Displacement is often a byproduct of growth. Imagine that visitor’s puzzlement over a story the next day: “City’s Loss Pinpointed in Census Count: Pittsburgh Accounted for Most of County’s Population Decline.”

According to estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau, the city’s population declined 2,610 between July 2016 and July 2017. Well, that’s not supposed to be happening. When Mayor Bill Peduto took office in 2014, he set a goal of growing the city’s population by 20,000 within a decade.

Advertise with us

If the visitor stayed through the weekend, a story on Saturday’s front page might have raised an eyebrow, too: “Plan Fizzles for Cultural District Housing, Parking Garage Project.”

No doubt, the plan was ambitious. More than 180 high-end condominiums, retail space and a new parking garage were on the drawing board. The Pittsburgh Cultural Trust, which owns the key parcels of land, had engaged The Davis Companies of Boston, a well-regarded firm that has completed an extensive renovation of the Union Trust Building, one of Downtown’s jewels. It was the Cultural Trust’s second ambitious attempt at developing the area. A decade ago, the $460 million RiverParc fell through, a victim of the 2008 credit crisis and disputes with the developer. In this case, conflicting visions between the Cultural Trust and Davis appear to be to blame.

In all three stories, caveats abound. Development deals falter all the time, only to re-emerge with new partners or a different scale, so the Cultural Trust’s ambitions may not be dead. Bloomfield’s demographics have been shifting steadily over the years; it’s the planned Milhaus apartment project displacing the Shursave IGA grocery store that has created a flashpoint.

As for the city’s population decline — those figures are estimates. The 2020 Census will tell the real story. In the meantime, no one can deny the increasing density in parts of the East End and elsewhere. Population declines could be taking place in the more remote of the city’s 90 neighborhoods.

The key to developing the city is achieving a balance that serves all markets.

Advertise with us

The city should help renters who are displaced from a buzzy neighborhood find lodging nearby, not flee for an outlying borough. Pittsburgh has reasonable housing costs that keep the middle class in city limits, owning homes, but that’s in the aggregate. Asking prices in, say, Highland Park may be eye-popping — so shoppers look to Morningside or Stanton Heights, to their benefit.

And while no one frets about how upper-income households will cope, there’s every reason to welcome high-end developments, too, such as what the Cultural Trust has in mind, plus the multimillion-dollar condominiums in Downtown and the Strip. The tax base benefits when people in that market can find options in the city, rather than heading straight for suburbs.

The prospect of luring Amazon looms over every conversation about development this year. As we’ve said before, the exercise has been helpful in imagining the region restored to its days as an economic powerhouse, and in planning how to attract other companies if Amazon locates its HQ2 elsewhere. But with or without Amazon, Pittsburgh benefits from more and better housing, while promoting underpopulated neighborhoods that are affordable by the nature of the market.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.