Should citizens of the United States stand during the playing or singing of the national anthem?

Yes, it is a sign of respect.

If the tune does not move you, that’s fine. It is simply a sign of respect.

Should NFL players stand for the anthem at the beginning of games?

Advertise with us

Yes, in this case, the act of respect is also part of the job — required by team owners.

As of last week, the owners reaffirmed this rule and reasserted their authority.

Many football fans wonder what took them so long.

Even so, the owners have given the players an out — they can stay in the locker room until the anthem has sounded.

That seems a rather wimpy option — for both owners and players.

Advertise with us

Staying in the locker room is no protest if protest is the point.

And why should owners give the players any choice?

Why not simply say: We pay you a great deal of money. We require, as part of the job, while you are on the job, that you stand for the anthem.

The owners might add what a lot of Americans feel: It’s not a lot to ask.

Sportscasters are in the bad habit of calling professional football players “warriors.” Warriors are people who go to war — laying down their lives for their country, for us.

Advertise with us

Standing for the anthem is a tribute to actual warriors.

And, again, if protest is the point, how meaningful a protest is it to kneel during the national anthem at a football game?

Yes, black Americans, even the privileged ones playing in the NFL, still have plenty to be angry about. But support for Big Brothers and Big Sisters, which Lavonte David of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers does, or the Boys and Girls Clubs of America, or Black Lives Matter, or the American Civil Liberties Union might be a better use of celebrity than kneeling during the anthem.

Football players who want to make a statement should look to Houston player J.J. Watt, who has a heart as big as his frame. He has to be the leading giver in the NFL right now. For whether it is paying for the funerals of children killed in school shootings or raising funds for hurricane relief in Houston ($37 million), Mr. Watt is present. He is up and doing, not kneeling. He has said, simply, that he wants the money he raises to be spent wisely and well and that he is in it for the long haul.

There is a difference between gesture and commitment.

Advertise with us

But, hey, if some NFL players feel that the gesture of kneeling during the anthem is vital to social justice, let them pay the fines that the league will now impose on them for doing so. Let’s see how many of them do. Their union says kneeling during the anthem is a matter of free speech. And that it is, albeit free speech at the workplace and on the bosses’ time.

Free speech always has a cost. And it is always worth the cost — when the speaker has something to say.