Two years ago, the state attorney general’s office handed out a remarkably detailed grand jury report on the history of sexual abuse by priests in the Altoona-Johnstown Diocese. The report identified perpetrators, traced the infection of pedophilia from one parish to the next over the course of a half century, outlined the diocese’s efforts to keep the misconduct under wraps, and showed how local authorities at times all but looked the other way.
Kathleen Kane, who was attorney general at the time, described the report as a “reckoning” for the diocese even though the alleged crimes were too old to prosecute.
The question now is, will other dioceses across the state have their own reckonings? They should.
As the Post-Gazette’s Peter Smith reported Sunday, another grand jury has spent about two years probing abuse in Pittsburgh and five other Pennsylvania dioceses, and its investigation appears to be complete. The current attorney general, Josh Shapiro, has brought charges against two priests — one each in Erie and Greensburg — because of the grand jury’s work. It’s unclear whether charges against other priests are forthcoming or whether a supervising judge will, as in the case of the Altoona-Johnstown investigation, authorize the release of a detailed report on the grand jury’s findings.
Doing so would show victims that an independent party, one above local loyalties, vigorously investigated their claims. It would subject perpetrators to the light of day, even if they have died or it is impossible for other reasons to bring charges against them. It would underscore society’s zero tolerance for criminal behavior in the church — an important message to send given revelations in the Altoona-Johnstown report that members of law enforcement in that diocese sometimes took a see-no-evil approach to reports of problems.
Dioceses around the country are more likely to crack down on errant priests and more open about the problem of child abuse than they used to be. Yet most, including Pittsburgh, have failed to render a thorough historical accounting of misconduct in their ranks.
A comprehensive airing of misdeeds and suggestions for preventing future abuse were the overarching benefits of the Altoona-Johnstown report, and people in other dioceses deserve the same. The public, accustomed over many years to hearing stories of abuse and seeing occasional criminal cases against priests, is entitled to learn the depth and breadth of the scandal for the first time. In some places, it may be less than feared. In others, it may be worse.
Only when all of the details are known can the church and public truly come to grips with what happened and face the future.
Confession is good for the soul, so it shouldn’t take a grand jury report to force the church to confront its sins in their entirety. But if that’s the case, so be it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.