The YMCA of Greater Pittsburgh has announced a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing and the closing of its Fifth Avenue fitness center Downtown. The financial troubles are sad news for the Y and for Pittsburgh, which has long benefited from its charitable and civic-oriented work. But Chapter 11 offers the Y the potential to emerge a stronger organization that could continue serving the city for years to come.

The Y announced Wednesday that it will close its Market Square fitness center June 8, and it previously disclosed plans to close its Delmont branch June 29. Like the Pittsburgh Public Schools and Diocese of Pittsburgh have done in recent years, and as the diocese is doing again now, the Y needs to right-size. It operates a bigger physical plant than other Y’s its size, and shedding the fitness center, which occupies leased space at 236 Fifth Ave., will help cut costs.

It may seem counterintuitive for the Y to abandon that site, which it opened in 2010, with so many more people living and visiting Downtown. However, officials concluded that the rent is too high to justify the expense. People have an increasing number of fitness options, from yoga-in-the-park programs to high-intensity workout clubs and ever-fancier home gym equipment, and that diversity of choice helps to explain lagging membership fees across the Y’s branches.

The cost-cutting is nothing new; since 2005, the Y has closed branches, deferred maintenance projects and shed programs that could be picked up by other nonprofits. This time, the cuts drew more attention because they involved a high-profile Downtown location and accompanied news of the bankruptcy filing. A Chapter 11 filing staves off creditors during reorganization efforts.

Advertise with us

To its credit, the Y is doing what it can to minimize the impact. If possible, employees will be offered jobs at other branches. A second Downtown fitness center, at the U.S. Steel Tower on Grant Street, will remain open. Other programs operated out of the soon-to-be-closed locations will be transferred to other branches.

Founded in 1854, the YMCA is one of the city’s oldest nonprofits. Like its slightly younger counterpart, the YWCA Greater Pittsburgh, it has met residents’ needs in critical ways, often working without fanfare as the city cycled through good times and bad. It’s still providing assistance to needy families. But now it also works on addressing the region’s educational and health disparities. It is needed as much today as it ever was.

The YMCA’s travails stand in stark relief to the positive vibe that has surrounded the YWCA Greater Pittsburgh in recent weeks. The YWCA — financially stable, officials there say — celebrated its 150th anniversary April 13 with a Downtown gala that attracted hundreds.

Chapter 11 offers the YMCA a shot at stability, too, and experience shows that change can yield surprising results. After closing its Hazelwood branch in 2016, for example, the Y began serving more children with programs in schools and other community locations. The Y’s impact on the neighborhood grew.

The Y has a well-rounded board of directors, and its CEO, Kevin Bolding, rightly sees this crossroads as part difficulty and part opportunity. There’s much reason to believe that the Y, which has lifted up so many others over the years, has the strength to save itself, too.