Bruno Manypenny was entering PNC Park for the April 27 game against the St. Louis Cardinals when a ballpark staffer stopped him and told him that his attire — a black-and-gold T-shirt emblazoned with the slogan “Spend Nutting, Win Nutting,” a poke at the Pirates’ owner Bob Nutting — was inappropriate for the ballpark.
As Mr. Manypenny told Pirates Prospects, a local blog covering the Pirates, he was asked to remove the shirt, turn it inside out or leave PNC Park. According to the team’s policy, the Pirates reserve the right to eject people “wearing clothing which, in the judgment of the Pirates, is indecent, derogatory, obscene or otherwise detracts from the experience of other guests.”
The shirt was none of those things. Mr. Manypenny, 33, removed it but he was surprised. A former season ticket holder, he had worn the shirt to games in years past. However, that was before the latest controversy surrounding Mr. Nutting’s management of the franchise.
Pirates fans were abuzz last winter as the team made a series of controversial personnel decisions, namely a trade that shipped longtime fan favorite Andrew McCutchen to the San Francisco Giants. As a result of these moves, the target of many fans’ ire was Mr. Nutting. A petition requesting that Mr. Nutting sell the team was circulated shortly after Mr. McCutchen was traded in January. That petition now has more than 60,000 signatures.
Criticism of a public figure like Mr. Nutting is fair game, particularly if that criticism is as passive as a T-shirt with a cheeky but not rude slogan. Mr. Nutting, who owns a number of newspapers, should know a little something about the First Amendent, and he long ago should have made sure that his overzealous staff did, too. If he’s going to anger the fans by trading favorite players, he should brace himself for the blowback.
Pirates spokesperson Brian Warecki later said the ballpark staffer who requested that Mr. Manypenny remove his shirt had made a mistake.
“The policy is enforced on a case-by-case basis,” Mr. Warecki said. “The security officials who encountered the guest deemed the shirt as contrary to our guest conduct policy. In this instance, the guest should not have been asked to turn his shirt inside out. All staff will be instructed of this interpretation of our policy.”
This is too little, too late. Mr. Manypenny’s enjoyment of a ballpark outing was disrupted by a team that all but strives to alienate its fans. After the trade of Mr. McCutchen and the petition against ownership, the Pirates should be happy to admit anyone who shows up for a game. The team owes Mr. Manypenny a fervent apology.
The Pirates, by the way, won that game, 6-5, in 11 innings. They were 17-15 going into last night’s game in Milwaukee. The season is still young.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.