To put it in stark terms: Ford is going to stop selling cars. It’s a shocking moment in American industrial history, even if the logic of the market has dictated the decision.
Ford announced last month that by 2020, it will discontinue all conventional sedans — the C-Max, Fiesta, Focus, Fusion and Taurus — for the American market. The company will shift production to SUVs, pickups and commercial vehicles. The Mustang sports car will remain. The compact Focus will become available as a model called Active, with the look of a crossover SUV. It will be built in China.
The company that invented mass production and developed the first popular passenger car in America, the Model T, is abandoning the very heart of its legacy. One hopes that Ford knows what it is doing — but there’s just as much reason to think that Ford is setting itself up for future decline.
Anyone with even a casual interest in the American car industry has observed the rise of the SUV and truck-like vehicles and the decline of the modest passenger car and station wagon. For reasons of practicality or fashion, more drivers want to be behind the wheel of a vehicle that looks like it could traverse a creek, even if puddles in a mall parking lot are the most forbidding territory it usually gets to approach. Minivans, packed with cupholders, began to rule the road for young families. The Honda Accord and Toyota Camry battled for domination in the market for practical sedans, winning top ratings, while the American carmakers churned out anonymous rides that populated rental-car fleets.
In the long march back to quality, American manufacturers gave it their best. The Chevrolet Impala, for example, is again this year’s top-rated large sedan from Consumer Reports. But the Japanese carmakers maintained a lock on the sedan market, even as it was shrinking, and their luxury lines dominated the upper ranks, along with European models. The Ford F-series truck, led by the F-150 pickup, has been the best-selling vehicle in America for years, with hefty profit margins to match.
Ford was lionized for not bottoming out during the crisis of the last decade, in which GM and Chrysler filed for bankruptcy and went heavy for government aid. Ford saw the storm clouds ahead and borrowed billions to get through the worst; CEO Alan Mulally was credited for being a visionary. Yet in recent years, Ford’s debt position has limited its options. It looks to top-selling, high-profit vehicles — big and thirsty SUVs like the Expedition and hulking pickups outfitted with every creature comfort — and thinks that more of these will carry the day. The market, after all, rules.
According to legend, Henry Ford offered the Model T in any color the customer wanted, as long as it was black. He valued simplicity and efficiency, and the shift to a smaller lineup may be a business decision in his tradition. But it’s more likely that he’d be appalled. It seems dangerous for a carmaker to abandon an entire segment of a market — the wide middle — while going long on SUVs and trucks. What happens when the fashion for rugged off-road rides fades, and Americans realize they don’t need the hauling power of a semi-industrial truck? Winding down a production line is much easier than starting one up. Ford Europe will continue making passenger cars, but the technology cannot be transferred at the flip of a switch.
The personal transportation industry is going through seismic changes, like every disrupted industry, but there is every reason to think that smaller, nimble and inexpensive vehicles are always going to have a place. Ford may believe it has little choice but to go with surefire successes of the moment. But seeing an American carmaker abandon the segment that made it mighty is more than poignant — it’s a warning sign.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.