The cause of reforming the United Nations — calling upon it to be all that it could and should be — goes back to Adlai Stevenson, who was the U.S. representative to that body under Presidents John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson, and Daniel Patrick Moynihan, who had the job under President Gerald Ford.
Mr. Moynihan even wrote a book about his experience — “A Dangerous Place.”
The U.N. remains dangerous because the level of hypocrisy is off the charts. Regimes that make a practice of human rights abuses opine and faux legislate on human rights.
And it is a dangerous place because it cannot fulfill its core function — to uphold international law and human rights, even when the abuses are egregious.
Now another eloquent U.S. ambassador to the U.N., as the post is informally known, Nikki Haley, is finding out the U.N. is a more dangerous place than ever.
The U.N. was unable to agree on even an investigation of Syria’s alleged use of chemical weapons, for example. That’s because Russia used its veto power as a permanent member of the Security Council to reject the proposal to investigate.
Moreover, the U.N. Security Council failed to renew the mandate of an investigatory body, the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons-United Nations Joint Investigative Mechanism. Created in 2015 by the Security Council and renewed for a second year in 2016, the agency had investigated previous chemical attacks in Syria. A single no vote from Russia last fall, however, amounted to a veto on the motion to continue the group’s investigations for another year.
Of course, the U.N. charter, which laid the groundwork for the United Nations in 1945, is to blame.
At that time, the five most powerful signatories to the agreement — the United States, Russia, England, France and China — gave themselves veto power. The Security Council also includes 10 other countries in rotating positions.
Changing the charter is almost certainly a non-starter. But what about this as a reform? No country should be allowed to veto an investigation or finding in an international case in which that country is a combatant.
Might a reform this modest, one day, be passed? The present Russian regime would certainly veto it. The present United States government might veto it, too.
Russia is an active participant in the war in Syria. The United States is a participant also, though more removed.
But think about this: As currently constituted, the United Nations cannot even tell the world the truth about what is happening in the world.
If the U.N.’s power players can tie its hands — to prevent even the investigation of atrocities — what use is it or can it ever be, for seeking, or keeping, peace?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.