While the Citizen Police Review Board and community groups help to monitor the city police bureau, discipline is best enforced from within. Vigorous self-policing keeps a culture of rot from setting in and builds public support for officers’ work.
The bureau showed an appreciation for this by firing an officer allegedly involved in an off-duty road rage incident and suspending and filing charges against another officer believed to have obstructed an investigation into the matter.
In May, a motorist, Jesse Smith, called 911 to say the driver of a Mercedes brandished a gun at him during an exchange of words at a Sheraden intersection. He provided a partial license plate number. According to court records, Officer Kaelen O’Connor used the information to identify the owner of the Mercedes as a fellow officer, Robert Kramer, but he left that information out of his official report and instead listed the suspect as “unknown.”
The investigation might have ended there, except Mr. Smith kept calling police for updates. Detective Dawn Mercurio began investigating the case in June, and it eventually was referred to the bureau’s Office of Professional Standards, created in 2015 to strengthen training, ethics and accountability. Mr. Kramer — charged with simple assault in August and now awaiting trial — was fired. On April 6, Officer O’Connor was charged with obstructing administration of the law, official oppression and other offenses. A training academy classmate of Mr. Kramer, he has been suspended without pay.
A number of other officers had a hand in responding to Mr. Smith’s 911 call. One, Raymond Toomey, a classmate of Mr. Kramer and Officer O’Connor, resigned earlier this month after video showed him kicking a man during an arrest on the South Side. Officials must examine the roles the other officers played in the case and come down hard on any who acted improperly. Chief Scott Schubert has insisted that no one else committed “criminal misconduct,” but the standard must be higher than that. If unpunished, even minor breaches of duty, ethics or the law proliferate and invite bigger lapses down the road.
While Pittsburgh has been spared the deadly-use-of-force scandals that have thrown cities such as Baltimore and Sacramento, Calif., into turmoil, the bureau has had its embarrassments. These include last year’s sentencing of former Sgt. Stephen Matakovich to federal prison for using excessive force, the 2014 sentencing of former police Chief Nathan Harper on theft-related charges and the 1997-2002 consent decree that placed the bureau under federal oversight because of a pattern of civil rights violations. The latter is the kind of thing that happens when departments fail to police themselves.
The Citizen Police Review Board grew out of the problems of the 1990s and remains the primary independent monitor of police activity. It’s been an aggressive advocate for the public. Other organizations, such as the Alliance for Police Accountability, also play a watchdog role. While departments always will need outside monitoring, they should strive to set high standards, enforce them vigorously and strive to give the outside groups as little to do as possible.
Chief Schubert last week said the bureau “will not tolerate” rogue conduct by its officers. Let’s hope this is a line in the sand.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.