An on-again, off-again approach to economic sanctions against Russia can add the advantage of flexibility to U.S. policy. At the same time, it is hard for other countries to follow America’s lead when signals are changed abruptly.
On Sunday, U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki R. Haley declared that the U.S. Treasury Department intended to impose new sanctions, based on various Russian misdeeds, most recently its defense of Syria’s apparent use of chemical weapons on its own population. The sanctions would be placed on Russian companies connected to the chemical weapons used in the alleged attack. On Monday, the White House walked back her statement, while leaving open the possibility of sanctions in the near future. On Tuesday, White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow elaborated, saying that Ms. Haley had “gotten ahead of the curve.” This back and forth unfortunately undercuts America’s credibility in international forums.
The switch was particularly costly to Ms. Haley, who tends to be in the front row of American officials administering the lash to Russia in New York. In fact, it calls into question the whole position of Ms. Haley, the former South Carolina governor, who was rumored at one point to be a potential successor to Rex Tillerson as secretary of state before CIA Director Mike Pompeo was nominated to that post.
Russia deserves to be sanctioned. It invaded Ukraine, it annexed Crimea and it has supported Syrian leader Bashar Assad as he has done his worst in Syria. Russian President Vladimir Putin has been busy assembling what can be seen as an alliance of countries disaffected with the United States, including Iran and Turkey, in the Eurasian region. He has taken some pleasure at tendencies toward fission in the European Union.
Yet the United States also has good reasons to want better relations with Russia, and President Donald Trump has shown some disposition to seek these. He congratulated Mr. Putin on his somewhat bogus March 18 electoral victory and has invited the Russian president to meet. There is every reason in the world for the two presidents to meet, given the depth and bulk of the issues between Russia and the United States, even though such a meeting risks giving the impression of U.S. approval of some of Russia’s mischief, including its interference in U.S. elections.
It is arguable that the decision to hold fire on more sanctions on Russia at this time was correct in terms of overall U.S. Russia policy. What didn’t make sense was to diminish Ms. Haley’s credibility as a foremost U.S. representative and spokesperson, particularly with no secretary of state as yet confirmed by the Senate. Mr. Kudlow on Tuesday took the occasion to say that “she’s done a great job as ambassador.” Yet a high-level walk-back of an ambassador’s public statement is hard to recover from. She might just quit.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.