The office, home and hotel room of the president’s personal lawyer, Michael Cohen, were searched and confidential papers were seized in a no-knock raid by the FBI on Monday.

What in the world is going on?

This is not the sort of thing that happens in America. It has never happened to a president and his lawyer before.

It is not the sort of thing that would be quietly accepted — by the press or civil libertarians — if it happened to a Democratic president.

Advertise with us

Yet this was not the doing of the special counsel, Robert Mueller. He passed whatever he suspected or found on Mr. Cohen back to the Justice Department. And its seems unlikely that the FBI would take such unprecedented action based only on an alleged election violation (paying hush money to someone who had a fling with the president a decade ago). If it did act this dramatically without a very good reason, the FBI’s already damaged credibility will be forever destroyed.

Former federal prosecutor and National Review legal correspondent Andrew McCarthy assures his readers that this is actually unlikely, given the prosecutorial checks and balances generally in place. He muses that the cover-up, for a sexual dalliance predating the Trump presidency, may finally give Trump-haters the scandal they seek to bring down the Trump presidency. Hence, a possible cover-up of consensual sex — and unseemly and unfaithful behavior — may accomplish what the search for Russian collusion could not.

Does any of this make sense?

Not as political theory, but perhaps as drama, or farce.

The search for a definitive, disqualifying scandal has been on since day one of the Trump presidency. So, to Never Trumpers and some lawyers and prosecutors, the internal logic works. This moment had to come; it was somehow inevitable.

Advertise with us

To many Americans, however, it is all — the scandals and the search for scandals — well, crazy: depressing, tawdry, irrelevant to life.

There is still so much we do not know. Mr. Cohen has been Mr. Trump’s personal lawyer for more than a decade. Their business affairs in the world of New York real estate and beyond are immensely complex. Speculating about the motivations of the prosecutors may assume motives not in evidence or beyond anyone’s knowledge. They had to make a strong case to a federal judge to obtain search warrants, asserting that the chance for criminal evidence overwhelms the standard protections of lawyer-client privilege.

But it is possible that, even if Mr. Mueller, various New York prosecutors and the FBI are acting in good faith, and within the logic and limits of the law and their professions, they have adopted a larger mission, which is unhealthy and unwise for the country — to bring down a president and to criminalize both his person and his politics. No matter what the president or his lawyer did in his private or business life, it is essential for the republic to endure.