National Public Radio has been doing an instructive series on “the right to be forgotten” — the right of a citizen to ask Facebook or Google to take down information that is untrue, in some cases malicious, or simply too personal to share with the world.
Or, barring taking it down, at least not underlining or highlighting it so that it is the first thing another person reads.
NPR has reported on the cases of several people who were simply maligned, in many instances with total fabrications and falsehoods and in other instances with partial ones.
In Europe it is possible to get a court order to be “forgotten” by Google. The right to privacy has some legal footing there, though not the equivalent of what we would call constitutional standing. In the U.S. it’s another matter. The First Amendment trumps just about all legal and even moral claims.
And yet the internet is to the First Amendment what so-called assault weapons and other weapons of war, now commercially available, are to the Second Amendment — modern technology changes everything.
And maybe it ought to help us refine how we think about constitutional principles.
Is it not strange that, in these times, college professors are investigated, intimidated and in some cases fired for scholarly thought that might violate leftist orthodoxy or offend someone — clearly a free speech violation? Yet Google can wrap itself in the First Amendment when a person’s career is destroyed by a lie and Google’s indifference?
Anyone can say anything about anyone on the internet. And often that broad license is employed. If the story is salacious enough, it will be popular and therefore underlined.
Most of the Americans slimed on Google had no recourse, and not even an answer from Google. Meanwhile, they went to job interviews and found the interviewer holding the false or malicious story in his hands. If you have to explain a blot on your name, however untrue and unfair, you are probably not getting the job.
There are two immediate questions here. One is: Does free speech inherently threaten privacy? Or is it the abuse of free speech that threatens privacy?
Isn’t this partially a matter of making distinctions and using common sense?
Again, as with the Second Amendment: We have a constitutional right versus the need for prudential action — to prevent real harm to real people. If an information platform refuses to publish a libel, is it really on a slippery slope toward curtailing debate on vital issues?
The late Judge Robert Bork got in hot water some years ago by asserting that there is no constitutional right to privacy. People were aghast. He was right, of course.
But most of us would say there is a natural right to privacy. The Constitution (in the Fourth Amendment) does speak of the right to be “secure in our persons, houses, papers and effects,” many of which are now electronic. Today they are usually unreasonably searched electronically.
Free speech is under attack in many spheres today. Privacy is under threat, in virtually every aspect of our lives. We need both. Maybe we can protect both by applying reason.
This brings us to the second question: Could Google not police itself and its users? Could it not referee purely personal material and attacks? Would it really be so hard to set a standard and apply it? Don’t limit any political debate; do limit attacks on the privacy of individuals or assaults on their good names.
Heretofore Google and the other social platforms have simply said, in effect, we can’t be bothered. Wrecked careers and reputations did not seem to count for much.
This will no longer fly. Free speech matters to all Americans, not just Google. Privacy still matters to some Americans, which means it must ultimately matter to Google.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.