A bill soon headed to Gov. Tom Wolf’s desk would allow judges to use risk assessment tools as a factor in setting bail in domestic violence cases. The legislation would afford additional protection to victims while setting in motion a process for ensuring the measure is effective and fair to defendants. Mr. Wolf has said he’ll sign the bill, which will help to ensure that what happened to Tierne Ewing is less likely to happen to someone else.
Sen. Camera Bartolotta, R-Monongahela, sponsored the bill and named it for Mrs. Ewing, a Washington County woman killed by her husband two years ago. Kevin Ewing was on house arrest and awaiting trial on domestic violence charges when he removed his ankle bracelet, went to his wife’s home and fatally shot her before killing himself. While it’s impossible to know whether Ms. Bartolotta’s bill would have made a difference in that case, it’s likely to help others.
It would allow a county’s president judge to authorize use of a risk assessment tool to determine whether defendants are likely to cause additional harm to their alleged victims. A Common Pleas or magisterial district judge would take the score into consideration in setting or denying bail. While offering additional protection to victims, Ms. Bartolotta noted, a favorable score for the defendant could result in a more moderate bail than otherwise might be the case.
Risk assessment is an increasingly sophisticated field being put to wider use. Allegheny County’s Department of Human Services has received national attention for using a screening tool in child welfare cases. While the department’s tool has received both support and criticism, its effectiveness is under evaluation by Stanford University.
Critics of the bill are concerned that a risk assessment tool in domestic violence cases would have an unfair impact on minority and poor defendants. However, defendants may have their bail reviewed at various points in the justice process, and Ms. Bartolotta has built in a step to make sure her legislation works as intended. The bill requires the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing to develop a model tool for judges to use and to evaluate it to ensure it is accurate and free of racial and economic bias.
There’s one more factor to consider: For the tool to work properly, judges must be trained in its use.
The Legislature is considering several other bills intended to safeguard domestic violence victims. One would require that defendants who are ordered to surrender firearms do so to law officers or licensed dealers — as opposed to family members, for example — and another would make it easier for victims to move from one public housing unit to another.
While these remain in the legislative pipeline, Ms. Bartolotta’s bill has passed both chambers and soon will be in Mr. Wolf’s hands. Domestic violence victims will be safer with Tierne’s Law, as it’s called, books.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.