Since the closing of the venerable Gimbels, Horne’s and Kaufmann’s department stores, a dearth of retail shopping has been the Golden Triangle’s Achilles heel. Even as the number of restaurants, cultural amenities, recreational opportunities and condominiums has grown in recent years, making Downtown a more vibrant place, retail has lagged conspicuously behind. Now, the Pittsburgh Downtown Community Development Corp. has a plan to jump-start this important economic sector, and merchants, cultural groups and civic leaders should line up squarely behind it.

The nonprofit wants to create a $100,000 pool to guarantee the leases of boutiques, bookstores and similar ventures that might want to locate Downtown but face barriers of one kind or another. For example, the owners of small enterprises might have trouble snagging leases with Downtown property owners concerned about the staying power of mom-and-pop operations or start-ups, especially those of first-time entrepreneurs. The development group’s plan is to step in when a small business fails, taking over lease payments until it can put a new tenant in place.

While the development group hasn’t nailed down the source of the seed money, there is little need to seek government funds. The owners of restaurants, office buildings and other established Downtown businesses should pony up because of enlightened self-interest. If the retail trade picks up, all of them will benefit. Downtown property owners also may be asked to offer discounted rents to retail entrepreneurs. In turn, entrepreneurs helped by the program would pay a surcharge of 1 percent to 2 percent of their leases, with that money going back into the pool to assist others.

The proposal is part of the development group’s strategy to create an “urban village” of niche boutiques, offering visitors something different from the chain stores common to suburban malls. Uniqueness characterizes the city’s sizzling restaurant scene; the Cultural District has entertainment the suburbs can’t match; and Downtown living is a special experience. Downtown shopping should stand out, too. The last thing civic leaders should do is emulate the malls, many of which are struggling.

Advertise with us

In 2011, the city Urban Redevelopment Authority and a handful of donors pooled more than $25,000 to turn 11 vacant storefronts into pop-up stores and exhibits. At least two, Boutique 208 and Fraley’s Robot Repair, had long runs on Sixth Street. Still going strong on Liberty Avenue is Amazing Books, which also has locations in Squirrel Hill and on the South Side. The pop-up project provided evidence of the city’s appetite for small-scale retail.

The Downtown shopping moonscape is starkly at odds with the city’s upward trajectory on so many other fronts. It’s time to fill the void. As much as Pittsburghers still love the old department stores, they aren’t coming back. The development group’s proposal offers the hope of something better — or at least something in step with the times.