On Friday night, Attorney General Jeff Sessions fired former deputy FBI director Andrew McCabe, on the recommendation of the FBI’s Office of Professional Responsibility, which consists entirely of above-the-fray FBI professionals.
This was not a political act, but it became one. Over the weekend, the president, Democrats on the Hill and many in the media turned it into more government by soap opera and the weighing of evidence and rendering of judgment by Twitter.
How’s that been working out for the country, so far?
All three parties forgot, again, to be adults. They chose to emote instead of quietly, soberly doing their duty.
How did Mr. McCabe get into trouble? He was, reportedly, found by the Office of Professional Responsibility to be less than totally candid with the bureau. He failed in his duty.
How has the FBI been compromised? Let us count the ways: The Hillary Clinton email situation. Treating Carter Page as a serious threat. Open hostility to Mr. Trump, in an organization that traditionally has been rigidly neutral. Too much politics and too little operating by the book at top levels — a failure of duty.
How did we get the special counsel? The president fired the head of the FBI based on pique — a failure of prudence, responsibility and, therefore, duty.
And the deputy attorney general, who should have had the Justice Department investigate the Russia matter, or at least formally restricted the special counsel’s probe, choked. That was another failure of duty.
How might the special counsel discredit himself? By straying far from the original justification for his investigation — Russian meddling. By investigating past Trump business practices instead. By succumbing to, in former prosecutor and National Review writer Andrew McCarthy’s phrase, “a boundless quest to hunt for undiscovered crimes, rather than an investigation and prosecution of known crimes.”
Searching for a crime to fit the man you want to prosecute is the very opposite of due process. It should be anathema to every thinking American.
From start to finish the series of scandals, missteps and misdeeds that began in the last presidential campaign and have morphed and multiplied since — the investigation of Hillary Clinton emails, the bumbling Trump campaign staff’s antics, the investigation of Mr. Trump himself by the special counsel, the misuse of the FISA courts, the probes by two sides on the House Intelligence Committee, and, finally, the sad realization of the profound politicization of the FBI — have been a failure of duty. What has been lacking is due process, and a broader sense of right process — basic professionalism and seriousness. And this certainly includes the president, who degrades himself and his presidency when he attacks the man investigating him.
Justice depends on a just and rational process. Government depends on this same seriousness, if it is to function.
The only persons who may have met that standard of seriousness — the only possible good guys in this story so far — may be the members of the FBI’s Office of Professional Responsibility and the Justice Department’s inspector general. Their work has been obscured by partisan static.
The IG ought to disclose everything he has found and concluded.
During Watergate, there were lots of heroes: Archibald Cox, Sam Ervin, Fred Thompson, Judge John Sirica, Sam Dash, Peter Rodino, Barbara Jordan, Woodward and Bernstein, the Supreme Court. Previously mostly unknown figures, like Mr. Ervin, came forward to defend American law and values. They became heroes, and tribunes of the American way.
In this long saga there are, so far, no heroes and few good guys — just a lot of compromised people chasing, and covering, their tails.
Perhaps Mr. Mueller will yet emerge as the hero. If he places the rule of law, and due process of law, above nailing the president’s hide to the wall, he will be a constitutional hero, as Sen. Sam Ervin was.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.