The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education earlier this year published a list of the 34 colleges or universities that have adopted or endorsed the “Chicago Statement.” The Chicago Statement is shorthand for a 2015 document released by the University of Chicago called the Report of the Committee on Freedom of Expression, guided by the university’s tradition of “free, robust and uninhibited debate.” While the document focuses on standards to be maintained at Chicago, it serves to rebuke other academic institutions that limit free speech and coddle the minds of their students.
The report affirms the University of Chicago’s “fundamental commitment is to the principle that debate or deliberation may not be suppressed because the ideas put forth are thought by some or even by most members of the University community to be offensive, unwise, immoral or wrong-headed.” It concludes with a commitment to protect freedom of expression at the university “when others attempt to restrict it.”
The 34 schools include well-known names — Princeton, Columbia, Georgetown. Liberal-arts colleges such as Amherst and Kenyon are on the list. The university systems of Missouri and Wisconsin have signed on. Yet the United States is home to more than 1,600 institutions of higher learning. In other words, only about 2 percent of the nation’s colleges have deemed it worthwhile to offer a full-throated support of freedom of expression.
In Pennsylvania, just one school has adopted the Chicago Statement: Franklin & Marshall College in Lancaster. Pittsburgh’s many institutions of higher learning would be wise to engage the ideas of the document and sign on.
The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education conducts an annual report on the state of free speech at individual campuses across the country. A “green rating” means the school’s policies nominally protect free speech. A “yellow” rating indicates an institution has “at least one ambiguous policy that too easily encourages administrative abuse and arbitrary application,” while a “red” rating indicates a school “has at least one policy that both clearly and substantially restricts freedom of speech.”
In its 2017 report, Carnegie Mellon University received a “green” rating, but the University of Pittsburgh, California University of Pennsylvania, and Indiana University of Pennsylvania all received a “yellow” rating. Duquesne University did not receive a rating.
With a growing number of states considering so-called “campus free speech” bills, Pennsylvania’s colleges and universities should be searching for ways to prove they will defend the right to free speech and open debate on their campuses without governmental intervention.
The Chicago Statement is far from a panacea. But its adoption does allow any school to prove it has a vested interest in promoting free and open expression. “Protecting” students from difficult concepts and creating ideological echo chambers has proved to have a negative impact on the academic environment.
Pittsburgh’s colleges and universities are known to be world-class. Supporting the broad-minded ideals of the Chicago Statement is another way to prove it.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.