When members of the Legislature learn about a serious flaw in state government, they should act quickly to address it. That is what state Sen. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Jefferson Hills, has pledged to do after a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette report about judges who illegally put impoverished defendants in jail for failing to pay fines and court costs.

Mr. Reschenthaler, who sits on the Judiciary Committee, said he will introduce legislation allowing district judges to impose community service on defendants who cannot afford to pay fines and costs stemming from traffic offenses. While this is a laudable step, legislators and the state Supreme Court also should ensure that continuing legal education programs for Common Pleas and magisterial district judges drive home the importance of properly handling cases with financially challenged defendants.

Judges may incarcerate offenders who refuse to pay fines and costs, but not those too poor to do so. In their Feb. 18 story, reporters Kate Giammarise and Christopher Huffaker reported that district judges regularly jailed people who lacked the means to pay and incorrectly filled out forms intended to keep that very thing from happening.

When they put people behind bars for failing to post at least some of what they owe in fines and costs, district judges are supposed to document their ability — and thus willful refusal — to pay. Instead, they often wrote in extraneous comments such as “multiple citations” that had no bearing on the cases or included remarks such as “defendant has no income” indicating an inability to pay instead.

Advertise with us

It all means judges have illegally deprived some people of their liberty and turned poverty into a jailable offense. This is no minor slip-up but a significant civil-rights issue. In addition, because the handling of poor defendants varies from one courtroom to the next, the judiciary is flouting constitutional guarantees of equal justice.  The pervasiveness of the problem means that the state Supreme Court, which oversees Common Pleas and district judges, needs to do a better job of minding the store.

Although he was a district judge before his election to the Senate in 2015, Mr. Reschenthaler said he did not know about the scope of the problem until the Post-Gazette’s report. While district judges may be happy to have community service as an option for impoverished defendants, they still have to determine accurately who can pay and who cannot, fill out the paperwork properly and apply standards consistently. This is where improved continuing legal education would come into play.

Traffic scofflaws don’t belong in jail anyway. Counties spend princely sums on jails, many of them overcrowded as it is. Confinement should be reserved for violent and incorrigible offenders, with alternative arrangements — house arrest, community service, work release or some combination thereof — the norm for other types of offenders.

Mr. Reschenthaler has expressed an interest in re-examining the role of constables, who get paid by the warrant and may find “failure-to-pay people” easy targets for arrest. He also questioned the justice system’s habit of imposing excessive fines and costs for minor offenses. Those are conversations worth having. The goal isn’t to make the justice easier on lawbreakers, just fair to everyone.