The shooting down Saturday by presumably the Syrians of an Israeli F-16 fighter underlines the increasingly dangerous equation of powers in the Middle East.

Because of the continued presence of U.S. armed forces in Iraq and Syria, and America’s alliance with Israel, the U.S. is automatically involved in whatever transpires there. Further, the various trigger points are not under U.S. control but instead often determined by our various allies, partners and enemies.

It has been the case for years that the Soviet Union, and then Russia, has armed its ally Syria with its most advanced military technology. The United States does likewise with Israel. As a result, confrontations between Israeli and Syrian forces have constituted a sort of proxy war between the United States and Russia, conducted through the rival armaments provided to their respective client states. The United States, in that sense, has usually won, though in no small part because of the quality and intensity of training of the Israel Defense Forces.

This time, the U.S.-made F-16 crashed down in northern Israel, returning from a bombing raid over Syria; the jet’s two-man crew survived. It isn’t clear who actually shot the plane down. There are Syrian, Iranian, Russian and Turkish national forces in Syria. There are also countless, more or less independent militias in Syria with anti-aircraft weapons. The Middle East is an open bazaar of weaponry.

Advertise with us

American ally Israel is threatened on a number of sides, from Hezbollah in Lebanon, potentially Hamas and Islamic Jihad in Gaza, and militias, backed by unseen forces, in Syria. Israel has determined, consistent with its longtime policy, to try to interdict military shipments and activities by its enemies in Syria. The price of sending drones, aircraft and forces into Syria until now has been low, or only financial, although knowledge of Israeli losses in this enterprise is scarce to nonexistent outside of Israel.

All of this, including U.S.involvement by choice or circumstance, takes place in the absence of meaningful negotiations regarding the future of Israel and Palestine. If there were discussions under way, the kind of proxy U.S.-Russian warfare that brought down the F-16 could be universally condemned as destructive to the peace process. Can’t some party to this conflict cook up an international process to involve Israelis, Palestinians, the United States, Russia, Syria, Iran, Lebanon and the Europeans? The negotiating table is better than the battlefield.

In the absence of a negotiating process, an F-16 in pieces on the ground can easily evolve into one more regional wars. If nothing else, the carnage of the war in Syria, which continues, should serve as a potent incentive to try to resolve these problems by talking, rather than by aircraft raids and anti-aircraft fire.