The city of Pittsburgh long has been concerned about a wave of retirements decimating the ranks of the 900-member police bureau. If some officers want to stay beyond 65, the mandatory retirement age now in place, it might make sense to keep them on. Public Safety Director Wendell Hissrich’s proposal to let officers stay until 70 is worth a look.

By the time they’re in their 60s, city police have had the opportunity to see and do it all. They’re likely to have worked in various zones and served in various roles, gaining knowledge, experience and street smarts even the brightest new recruits will lack. It seems a waste to dispense with all of that just because of a 65th birthday, especially when the loss of dozens of senior officers by 2023 may tax recruitment efforts and the bureau regularly loses a certain number of younger members to suburban departments thought to have better working conditions. If older officers “want to stay here, why not keep them here in the city,” Mr. Hissrich said, “and keep their experience and their knowledge and their training here in the city? That’s what’s behind this.”

It’s trite to say people are living longer these days. More important, many are able-bodied and clear-headed deep into retirement. Pennsylvania voters in 2016 approved a referendum allowing judges to stay on the bench an additional five years, until they’re 75.  Because they have a career-long incentive to stay fit and sharp, many police officers also are well-suited to remain on the job past 65.

Of course, the city must weigh the financial impact of letting the most senior, highest-paid officers remain on duty for an additional five years. Mayor Bill Peduto wants to have the city removed from state financial oversight. The elimination of monitoring and an increase in the mandatory retirement age for police could set the stage for salary and benefit spikes to be foisted on taxpayers.

Advertise with us

There’s also the potential impact on the city pension fund, which only eight years ago was at risk of a state takeover because of severe under-funding. A longer time on the job, at an increasing rate of pay, translates into fatter pensions and a greater fund liability. The city must not get in over its head again.

Even if Mr.  Hissrich’s proposal makes financial sense, there are other considerations to work through before officers are invited to stick around. Those electing to stay on the job should have to demonstrate their fitness. The city also must promise to deploy them for real police work, not relegate them to the desk-bound bureaucracy where they’re neither heard nor seen.

The point is that they be heard and seen, with the city making maximum use of these officers’ expertise. At 69, even the fittest officers may be hard-pressed to chase down suspects in their 20s. But they would make excellent candidates for neighborhood beat patrols and specialty units, and the city might assign its oldest officers to work with its youngest in a special mentorship program designed to  facilitate knowledge transfer.

As Pittsburgh experiences an exciting period of growth and change, it’s good to have veteran police officers provide stability. Mr. Hissrich may be on to something.