After more than 75 years, the Cleveland Indians have decided to retire the controversial Chief Wahoo logo at the start of the 2019 season, much to the betterment of Major League Baseball, sports and our common culture.
The Chief Wahoo icon has been a mainstay of Cleveland baseball at least since 1947, though some date its origins as far back as 1932. Its visage has long graced the Indians’ uniforms, ballparks and merchandise. For many, the grinning, red-faced, feather-wearing Indian was a silly yet memorable ambassador of the American pastime.
But for Native Americans, Chief Wahoo was a crude, racially insensitive caricature of their ethnicity.
For more than 25 years, Native Americans have protested the Cleveland Indians’ team name and the Chief Wahoo logo. Before a protest in 2012, the Cleveland American Indian Movement described the logo as “exploitative, bigoted, racist and shameful.” How can such an indictment be dismissed?
Many have decried Chief Wahoo’s retirement as a social travesty, as political correctness run amok. But the reality is that there have been innumerable words, practices and behaviors that Americans have retired for the sake of civility and respect over the years. The use of “blackface” in entertainment, for example, was discarded long ago. At a certain point, it became unthinkable.
Cynics will be quick to point out that the motivation for waiting until 2019 to phase out Chief Wahoo — and perhaps the motivation to phase him out at all — is business. The team likely wants to sell its remaining supply of Chief Wahoo-branded apparel this season but have the offensive logo in the rearview mirror by the time of the 2019 MLB All-Star Game, which will be played in Cleveland.
The Indians had already ratcheted down Chief Wahoo’s prominence in recent years, as evidenced by the team’s decision to use the icon only as a secondary logo beginning in 2016. But as Cleveland’s baseball team has returned to prominence over the past several seasons — having reached the MLB postseason for multiple seasons in a row for the first time since the late 1990s and enjoying a trip to the World Series in 2016 — the time must have finally seemed right to permanently lay Chief Wahoo to rest.
Whatever the motive, it was time.
Make no mistake, the retirement of Chief Wahoo does not even begin to undo the unimaginable pain and suffering endured by Native Americans over the past several centuries. It’s a token, but an important one. It’s a token of civility and respect.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.