The United States on Friday again certified Iran’s observance of the terms of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action agreed upon in 2015 between China, France, Germany, Russia, the United Kingdom, the United States and Iran. It traded Iran’s development of its nuclear weapons program for the other parties’ relaxation of economic sanctions against it.
Some American political elements, including candidate and now President Donald Trump, and Israel had expressed strong opposition to the Obama administration having agreed to the JCPOA after two years of hard negotiations. The opponents’ argument was, basically, that economic sanctions were squeezing Iran hard enough that ultimately it would have had to give up its nuclear program without an agreement. The United States and Israel were also busily using technical means to try to sabotage Iran’s program. There were also various threats of military action against Iran if the sanctions didn’t work to stop its program’s development.
The argument of those favoring the accord were, basically, that it removed from the world scene and, particularly, from the Middle East, for a time one more nuclear power. The list of nuclear weapons-holding countries currently includes China, France, India, North Korea, Pakistan, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States; Israel is believed to have nuclear arms, but keeps its standing ambiguous.
There was also as part of the pro-JCPOA-agreement argument the possibility extended that Iran’s agreement to it would serve to help moderate elements in the Iranian political picture, including President Hassan Rouhani, who is identified with the accord, and, in general, to draw Iran further into the international community of nations through economic as well as political pressure. Recent popular demonstrations in Iran may indicate that there was some truth to that part of the pro-accord argument.
In general, the other parties to the JCPOA have taken advantage of the economic opening in the Iran market that it produced. The United States has not, except for a big airplane sale by Boeing. If the United States were to pull out, as some advocate, the other parties would not follow suit, to America’s economic and political disadvantage. An American withdrawal from the JCPOA would also serve as another signal that the presidency of Mr. Trump was not a time to make agreements with the United States, given its record of already withdrawing from the Paris climate accord and the Trans-Pacific Partnership and insisting on renegotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement with Canada and Mexico.
Mr. Trump is hoping the Republican-controlled Congress will take action to relieve him of the responsibility he has to review the Iran agreement for its compliance every 90 days, with the next round scheduled for mid-May, with the embarrassment to the left and the right, at home and abroad, it can bring him. Given the state of Congress, such action is unlikely to occur.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.