With regard to United States’ policy in the Middle East, particularly toward Turkey and the Kurds, a sharp contradiction between what President Donald Trump said it was on Nov. 24 and what the Pentagon said it was on Jan. 14 has left Americans and the many other parties to the matter up in the air and perhaps dangerously confused.

With the defeat of Islamic State forces, first, in Mosul in Iraq, and then in Raqqa, the IS capital in Syria, Mr. Trump told Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, in a phone call, in an effort to improve U.S. relations with longtime ally Turkey, that the United States would stop providing arms, training and other support to Kurdish forces fighting in the region.

Turkey strongly opposes anyone providing military aid to the Kurds, based on their effort in Turkey to oppose the government in their campaign to achieve eventual independence for a Kurdistan. The Turks had, however, more or less accepted U.S. military support of Kurdish forces in the war against the IS as the agent of terrorism and Islamic extremism, in Iraq and Syria. With that war basically over, however, Turkey and its president, Mr. Erdogan, had argued strongly, and, until now, apparently successfully, that U.S. military aid to the Kurds should cease.

On Sunday, the Department of Defense announced that the United States, through some 2,000 American troops now in Syria, would be training and equipping a 30,000-man Kurdish army based along the Turkish border, ostensibly to prevent a resurgence of the IS in the area. The U.S. justification for the pullout, issued in November, was to encourage a political settlement in Syria after the civil war, and to counter Iranian influence in the region.

Advertise with us

The Turks basically hit the roof at the new U.S. position of support to be provided for a large Kurdish army on their southern border. Mr. Erdogan pledged to “drown” it. The prospect thus arises of U.S. forces supporting Kurdish forces fighting Turkish forces, or even of U.S. forces fighting forces of U.S. NATO ally Turkey on behalf of the Kurds. The prospect immediately arises of Turkey’s denying further use of its airbases to U.S. military aircraft now using them to carry out airstrikes in Iraq, Syria or elsewhere in the region.

Another disturbing question that this controversy raises is whether Mr. Trump changed his mind on the issue of continued U.S. military support of the Kurds in Iraq and Syria, or whether the Defense Department is now pursuing its own policy in the region, independent of the White House. Its leaders may feel that they can do that, given that the secretary of defense, the national security adviser and the White House chief of staff are all military officers.

Whatever is going on, and whatever U.S. policy now is toward the question of military support to the Kurds, it needs to be sorted out urgently before the appalling prospect of combat between U.S. and Turkish forces becomes a reality, through internal U.S. government confusion, manifested in crossed signals, or as a result of bad decisions.