So far, leaders of the House and Senate have refused to abolish the security teams that patrol parts of the Capitol Complex with evidently little to do except help lawmakers feel important and, perhaps, protect them from themselves. If legislative leaders won’t do the right thing, rank-and-file members should pressure them to act.

Days after news outlets revealed that the Senate’s security director resigned amid a sexual harassment investigation, Liz Navratil of the Post-Gazette and Angela Couloumbis of The Philadelphia Inquirer reported Monday that the body’s 14-member security force operates in near secrecy, with virtually no accountability except to Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson. The Senate denied the reporters access to incident reports the guards file, saying they’re exempt under the state’s right-to-know law. It’s worth noting that the Legislature enacted the right-to-know law and granted itself this exemption, along with many others pertaining to public records.

Even if the Senate had done the right thing and turned over the reports, it would be difficult to piece together a complete picture of the guards’ work. That’s because there are no written guidelines for when the guards must file incident reports. One can see the convenience of that arrangement. If a senator is drunk and causes a disturbance after hours, for example, it’s nice not to have to file a report about that. Just settle him down, get him a cab and pretend it never happened.

Megan Martin, Senate secretary and parliamentarian, said the secrecy stems partly from the need to give senators and their staffers “a degree of privacy.” But they shouldn’t expect privacy in what is ostensibly a public building. If they want privacy, they should go home. Most Pennsylvanians don’t have privacy in the workplace, let alone a personal security service to provide a veil of secrecy.

Advertise with us

Ms. Martin’s remarks go to the heart of what is wrong with Harrisburg political culture. Generously compensated lawmakers with an exaggerated sense of their importance arrogate to themselves privileges denied to the taxpayers and do everything they can to keep Pennsylvanians in the dark.  The secrecy surrounding the Senate’s KGB-like security team is just the latest example.

Last month, Ms. Navratil and Ms. Couloumbis reported on a secret payout of about $248,000 that House Democrats authorized to settle a sexual harassment claim against Rep. Thomas Caltagirone of Berks County. When asked to explain the payout, House Minority Leader Frank Dermody of Oakmont declined, citing confidentiality language in the settlement. It’s clear where his constituents rank on his priority list.

Without the Senate requiring guards to file reports and releasing the reports that have been filed, it’s impossible even to know how busy they are. An official job description says the guards, who are unarmed and lack arrest powers, provide protection against fire, trespassers and theft. That sounds remarkably  like the work of the Capitol Police, a 105-member, fully accredited police department that also patrols the Capitol Complex and reports to Gov. Tom Wolf’s administration.

There’s no need for the Senate to have its own security force. The House needs to get rid of its private security team, too. This is an election year, and that means an opportunity to reform what may be one of the worst legislatures in America. If they intend to seek re-election, lawmakers would be well-advised to become champions of transparency.