Israel may now be veering toward a one-state solution, annexing all of the West Bank, as opposed to the two-state, Israel-Palestine formula for resolution of the 72-year-old Middle Eastern issue that the United States and most of the rest of the world have been pushing for decades now.

The Israelis, to the degree that there is a common Israeli position on the issue, have in recent years expressed at least an open mind toward negotiating a two-state solution with the Palestinians, with the United States playing a role in the negotiations. Any wave toward such an agreement has always broken, first, on the Israelis’ adherence to expanding, rather than relinquishing their settlements in the West Bank, which would serve as the land in a land-for-peace pact. The Palestinians have remained hamstrung by their internal differences, with tame Fatah predominant in the West Bank and more combative Hamas in Gaza.

Three elements have changed. First, the United States has shifted its position. President Donald Trump has declared Jerusalem the capital of Israel, indicating a strong tilt by his administration in Israel’s favor. In the process, he had ruled America out as an at least nominally neutral arbitrator in the eyes of the Palestinians, given the importance of Jerusalem to them, politically and religiously.

Second, Mr. Trump has put his son-in-law, Jared Kushner, in charge of developing America’s plan for resolving the Israeli-Palestinian problem. Mr. Kushner’s family real estate company has close financial ties to Israeli financial institutions and business figures. Third, some of the Sunni Arab states, notably Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and, as ever, Egypt, have given a quiet green light to a one-state solution. They clearly feel that the Palestinians are sufficiently weakened that they can get away with selling them down the river on the chances of ever achieving a negotiated, independent Palestine.

Advertise with us

There are major dangers in this new situation, assuming that one of the parties in it does not blow it up. For Israelis, the problem with a one-state solution is that Israel could end up neither Jewish nor democratic. If the Palestinians were given equal rights in a single state, Jewish Israelis would be outnumbered. The other alternative, with Palestinians having limited rights in the one state, would resemble, sadly, apartheid South Africa and the international boycott, divestment and sanctions movement, already growing in strength, would have a field day.

The more radical, violent Palestinian elements would become even more difficult to deal with than they are now.

If America’s and the world’s goal is a sustainable peace in the Middle East, based in part on some sort of justice for the Palestinians and the preservation of a democratic, Jewish Israel, the one-state solution option which is now gaining ground, in no small part through American actions, will not contribute to such an outcome. A responsible American position would be to discourage the Israelis from such a path now, before they go any further.