Most people go to the bank when they need a loan, but a handful of Duquesne City School District employees dipped into the public treasury instead. While taking personal loans out of public money is a bad practice on its face, these individuals’ use of a financially struggling school district as a cash machine is reprehensible. The Legislature should pass a law making it illegal to take personal loans from government accounts.
State Auditor General Eugene DePasquale discovered the 22 loans — all interest-free — while auditing district records for the period July 2012 through June 2016. The bad judgment emanated from the top. Then-superintendent Barbara McDonnell took 11 loans totaling $23,140 and allowed the others, collectively totaling $18,100, for a principal and two other employees.
Duquesne has been classified as financially distressed since 2000, and it closed its high school program in 2007, sending those students to other districts. In 2012, Duquesne went into state receivership and closed its middle-school program, sending still more students into the schools of neighboring communities. Duquesne’s loan recipients, especially the superintendent, should have seen the need to devote every available dollar to student needs.
Instead, they used general fund money to meet their own needs. Those seeking the loans provided little written explanation for wanting them. The people riding herd on the troubled school district — the school board, receiver and chief recovery officer — never approved them.
Ms. McDonnell simply submitted her monetary requests to a payroll clerk, “essentially approving her own loans,” Mr. DePasquale’s audit said. The clerk also took loans, which were processed by a relative, the business manager. There were no written loan contracts. However, informal repayment plans were developed by a business consultant, who in doing so had to take time away from helping Duquesne navigate its choppy financial waters.
The district described the loans as salary advances secured by the recipients’ future pay, and it insisted there was nothing nefarious afoot. All of the money was paid back.
Still, there are a lot of mistakes to correct here. Ms. McDonnell and the other employees should have known better than to take loans from their troubled employer. They arrogated to themselves a source of funds, an informal loan process and interest-free terms unavailable to Duquesne’s hardworking taxpayers or even other district employees.
Employees who knew about the practice should have reported it to the school board or other authorities. The receiver and chief recovery officer should have been paying closer attention to Duquesne’s books; that’s why they are there.
Mr. DePasquale has asked the state Ethics Commission to investigate the loans, noting that state law prohibits the use of public office for personal gain. But this is as much about promoting good government statewide as it is about the ethics of a few individuals. The Legislature should send a zero-tolerance message by making loans of this type a criminal offense.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.