In his analysis of Tuesday’s special election for a U.S. Senate seat from Alabama, GOP strategist Karl Rove got in a good line: “It takes a very special Republican to lose in Alabama.” Republican candidate Roy Moore was up to the task.
The former Alabama Supreme Court chief justice was already nationally known for being removed from the bench twice for disobeying the law, based on his Christian fundamentalist beliefs. The recent credible accusations of sexual predations upon teenage girls decades ago added a new dimension to his persona. He wasn’t just willing to pervert bedrock American principles on the separation of church and state; he was someone who’d deviate from basic human decency.
He lost to Doug Jones, a former U.S. attorney who’s a garden-variety Democrat by national standards but could be considered a raging liberal on the spectrum of Deep South politics. Mr. Jones ran a race that focused on Mr. Moore’s unsuitability for national office. Most of his campaign signs did not identify him as a Democrat, a smart move in a state that Republican presidents have won every year since 1980 and which has not sent a Democrat to the U.S. Senate since 1992. That candidate was Sen. Richard Shelby, who switched to the Republican Party in 1994.
Mr. Shelby played a significant role in his fellow Republican’s defeat. The Sunday before the election, he said on national TV that “I didn’t vote for Roy Moore. But I wrote in a distinguished Republican name,” having voted by absentee ballot. “The state of Alabama deserves better.” It turns out that nearly 23,000 write-in votes were cast — roughly the number of votes that provided victory for Mr. Jones.
It’s tempting to see the election result as a referendum on the presidency of Donald Trump, but it’s not. The president did offer his full-throated support for Mr. Moore in rallies and tweets. In the GOP primary for the seat in September, Mr. Trump had backed Luther Strange (the sitting senator, appointed after Jeff Sessions vacated the office to become attorney general) over Mr. Moore. The support for Mr. Strange stemmed from a president’s instinct to support the party’s establishment. A similar calculation applied to the general election. Mr. Trump’s stumping for Mr. Moore always emphasized the need to keep a Republican in the seat, to maintain its narrow edge in the Senate.
But the fact remains that Alabama is a deeply red state, conservative socially and politically, and generally supportive of the president’s agenda. The race was a rejection of Roy Moore, whose retrograde worldview would bring embarrassment to Alabama if thrust into the U.S. Senate. Mr. Jones distinguished himself as a federal prosecutor by winning murder convictions of two Ku Klux Klan members in a black church bombing. He will enjoy the national spotlight for some time to come, but Democrats are dreaming if they think his win represents a renaissance for the party in Alabama.
The biggest loser in Tuesday’s election is Steve Bannon, the self-styled renegade Republican who backed Roy Moore to the hilt, all in the name of making a hash of the Republican Party establishment. His reputation emerges from the election as rumpled as his grooming habits.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.