Whatever one thinks of the group’s politics, the Pittsburgh chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America deserves credit for bringing competition to two local officeholders who are up for re-election this year. No elected official should run unopposed. Because they discourage compromise and encourage complacency, safe seats are a plague on the political system.

Emboldened by the upstart victories last fall of two of their endorsed candidates — Mikhail Pappas, who defeated incumbent District Judge Ronald Costa of Morningside, and Anita Prizio, who defeated incumbent Republican Ed Kress for the District 3 Allegheny County Council seat— the Democratic Socialists are back for more. In the spring Democratic primary, Sara Innamorato, who has a marketing background, intends to challenge Rep. Dom Costa, D-Stanton Heights, while Summer Lee, who has a law degree from Howard University, plans to run against Rep. Paul Costa, D-Wilkins.

As the Post-Gazette’s Chris Potter pointed out in a story Sunday, the group’s choice of contests is interesting because the Costas are among Pittsburgh’s best-known political families, one that also includes state Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, and Guy Costa, the chief operations officer in Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration. Other incumbents might make softer targets, but again, the Democratic Socialists get credit for standing in the way of what otherwise could be automatic re-elections.

Elected officials don’t own their seats, and no matter how well they do their jobs, they shouldn’t feel slighted when someone chooses to run against them. Representing the people is a privilege that voters have the prerogative to rescind each election cycle. The Costas, long committed to public service, understand that. For their part, the Democratic Socialists don’t have anything against the Costas; they’re just giving voters a choice, something Democrats and Republicans alike should do more often in elections in and around the city.

Advertise with us

In November, Mr. Peduto and city council members Dan Gilman, Theresa Kail-Smith and R. Daniel Lavelle, all Democrats, won re-election without Republican opposition. One-party rule does nothing to make the city more vibrant. The three council members had no primary opponents, either, meaning they didn’t have to break a sweat all year.

Paul Costa has faced minimal opposition since his election to the Legislature in 1999 and Dom Costa has had none since voters decided in 2008 to send him to Harrisburg. That’s absurd. But it’s also in keeping with statewide trends.  In the 2016 legislative election cycle, 86 percent of incumbents had no primary challengers, and nearly 49 percent of general-election races featured candidates from only one of the two major parties, according to data analyzed by Ballotpedia.

Politics should be a marketplace of ideas, and re-election campaigns should be an opportunity for voters to maintain course or go in a new direction. The entry of Democratic Socialists into the political arena is an invitation for other candidates to jump into races, too.