The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Monday that the Trump administration can implement a ban on travel to the United States by most citizens of Chad, Iran, Libya, North Korea, Somalia, Syria and Yemen and some from Venezuela, pending rulings by two lower courts. The court’s action raises some interesting questions, apart from what the Supreme Court’s ultimate ruling will be on the issue.

Not at question is the right and duty of an American president to ban citizens of a country from traveling to the United States if they pose a threat to our lives and safety.

Courts’ objections to previous versions of the ban centered on the fact that Chad, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen are majority-Muslim countries, suggesting that the apparent focus on religion made the ban unconstitutional. A counterargument would be that not only are two new countries on the list, North Korea and Venezuela, not Muslim-majority nations, but also that each of the Muslim-majority nations also has among its population non-Muslims, notably Iran and Syria, although many of Syria’s Christians were driven out of the country during its civil war.

Another problem is that some nations, notable hosts of terrorists, including Afghanistan, Egypt, Iraq and Saudi Arabia, are not on the list, in spite of the Saudis and Egyptians who numbered among America’s 9/​11 attackers. That would call into question the whole concept of the list, raising the question of why some obvious countries were omitted from it, for whatever reason. There is also the problem that, if exclusion is based on nationality, the ban potentially includes 6-month-old babies as well as bona fide terrorists.

Advertise with us

When Mr. Trump first spoke of his ban on Muslims traveling to the United States, there was the sense that it was a temporary measure, designed to provide a breathing spell for U.S. authorities to tighten up on screening potential travelers to the United States. The nearly a year that he has been in power has provided the opportunity for the imposition of sharper criteria for the examination of applicants for visas. That fact raises the possibility that the more universal ban is no longer necessary. Immigration to the United States has been basically cut in half. Even the number of foreign students applying to American colleges and universities has declined significantly.

Courts, including probably eventually the Supreme Court ruling on the constitutionality of the ban, will take into account primarily the legal basis for it. But it is nonetheless a very political measure, bearing on U.S. relations with the eight countries on the list and others. Another group not dealt with is naturalized citizens of other countries, including America’s European allies, some of whom may even have fought as jihadists in the wars in Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria.

In the past, the United States has not done too badly leaving it to consular officers in American embassies abroad and immigration officers at ports-of-entry to screen potential entrants, based on their experience and judgment, not on universal bans based on citizenship.

But the next move on the issue is up to the courts.