When they go to court against their abusers, victims of domestic violence may have to worry about safeguarding their kids, finding a new place to live or making ends meet. They shouldn’t have the added burden of delivering a protection-from-abuse order to the police station and asking officers to serve it. PFAs should be processed like warrants, which is to say they should be served by police officers, sheriff’s deputies or constables without the assistance of victims or their families.
The inadequacy of the current system came to light after the death of 20-year-old University of Pittsburgh student Alina Sheykhet, whose body, beaten and stabbed, was found in her Oakland apartment Oct. 8. Police have charged her ex-boyfriend, Matthew Darby, 21, with her death.
In September, Ms. Sheykhet went to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court to get a PFA against Mr. Darby, saying he had broken into her apartment the previous morning. A judge granted a temporary PFA and set a hearing for Oct. 5.
However, the Oct. 5 proceeding was postponed because Mr. Darby had not been served with the temporary PFA. Ms. Sheykhet did not know — her family said nobody had told her — that it was her responsibility to take the order to a police station and ask officers to serve it.
After the postponement, she and her parents, Elly and Yan Sheykhet, went to the city’s Zone 4 station in Squirrel Hill to deliver the temporary PFA and have it served. Officers told her she needed to provide Mr. Darby’s complete address and, according to Ms. Sheykhet’s parents, belittled her for not having it. The city maintains that Ms. Sheykhet was treated politely. The city officers contacted their counterparts in Westmoreland County, who served Mr. Darby later that day in his workplace in Greensburg.
The authorities could have served him as early as Sept. 26, when he was in the Allegheny County Jail on a criminal trespass charge related to the break-in at Ms. Sheykhet’s apartment. But the system is not designed for easy enforcement of PFAs; the Allegheny County Jail, for example, doesn’t know about a PFA unless police make it aware of one or unless an inmate has a criminal charge for violating one.
Read More
Common sense and simple decency are needed here. Once a judge signs a PFA, the job of verifying the defendant’s address and serving the order should fall exclusively on law-enforcement officers. Victims shouldn’t have to carry the ball; consider the absurdity of a burglary victim having to to take an arrest warrant to a police station and asking officers to serve it on the suspect. Matters involving PFAs are split between civil and criminal courts but deserve to be addressed entirely in the latter.
Second, counties must do a better job of communicating with one another. In February, Indiana County authorities charged Mr. Darby with rape and other offenses in an unrelated case. Perhaps those charges should have affected his ability to get bond on the criminal trespass charge involving the break-in at Ms. Sheykhet’s apartment. Perhaps his bond in Indiana County should have been revoked following the issuing of the temporary PFA and filing of the criminal trespass charge here.
Ms. Sheykhet’s parents are supporting legislation that would put certain domestic violence defendants on GPS monitoring. That is worth exploring. Ms. Sheykhet’s tragic death highlights the need to treat domestic violence cases with greater gravity and to make sure the full resources of the justice system are brought to bear for victims.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.